3 ms·
Basically your examples are about how to navigate a text based application--mostly web and CRUD. What about a PCB layout program? What about Blender and anima
by bsder 6y ago
Basically your examples are about how to navigate a text based application--mostly web and CRUD.
What about a PCB layout program? What about Blender and animation? What about video editing? What about a 3D modeler?
If you are using an immediate-mode UI, you probably aren't making a text-based CRUD system--especially as immediate-mode UI's tend to be remarkably bad at text rendering.
A UI toolkit doesn't magically make every application accessible. If the aforementioned applications are to be accessible, that application has to change in major ways.
Not everything is text.
Forcing everything through that narrow lens is an impediment.
- chrismorgan 6y agoNeither Raph nor I were ever saying that the UI toolkit can magically make everything accessible; rather, we were saying that it’s roughly impossible to make an application accessible without support from the UI toolkit. These are very different things. (I’m afraid the terminologies we were all using contained some ambiguities that led to us talking at cross-purposes. I was always talking about framework concerns, since this whole discussion is all about the framework.) Any fancy components will still need to be able to notify any accessibility tech what they are. I contemplated saying more about other types of programs like those you mention, but decided that they’re really no different, beyond Tab being far less useful and often justifiably repurposed. The “canvas” parts may easily be just a black box that isn’t exposed to accessibility tech, but all of the rest of the UI around it (menus, configuration panels, property sheets, &c.) will still need to be exposed properly.
- mwcampbell 6y agoAlso, a good GUI framework should help the application developer decompose even a highly custom UI for a niche, non-CRUD application into widgets. As part of that, it should help the developer implement accessibility for those widgets. It's not hard to do much better than Win32 here, and probably not hard to do better than Cocoa as well.