3 ms·
Legacy admission, of course.
by michaelt 6y ago
Legacy admission, of course.
- MiroF 6y agoPeople without merit getting admitted to top law schools because of legacy/donors happens, but not nearly as much as some people seem to think. Legacy admits are not necessarily without merit. My guess is that most of the low merit admits are people with significant political influence that the school thinks it would be beneficial for law students to network with (people like Hunter Biden who went to Yale law, Tiffany Trump, etc.) Those people are never going to get close to an actual clerkship though. Could those downvoting explain why?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- csa 6y ago> Tiffany Trump ... who went to Georgetown law (typically in the 10-20 rank range). Note that this is the best she could do when her father was running for president.
- gamblor956 6y agoTo followup: based on the average GPA of Georgetown Law admits, Tiffany Trump would have had to make the UPenn Dean's List to have a competitive GPA. The list is public. She never showed up on that list. Ergo, she did not have a competitive GPA. It's possible she may have had a good LSAT, but she would have needed a very high score to offset the low GPA. As Georgetown Law appears to have been the most prestigious law school that would admit her, this suggests she was a "legacy" admit (meaning, admitted due to her parents or application sponsors rather than on her own merits).
- MiroF 6y agoThat's not what a legacy admit is defined to be.
- gamblor956 6y agoThat's exactly what a legacy admit is defined as. What non-standard definition are you using?
- xdavidliu 6y ago"Legacy preference or legacy admission is a preference given by an institution or organization to certain applicants on the basis of their familial relationship to alumni of that institution." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legacy_preferences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legacy_preferences
- wtallis 6y agoLegacy admissions usually refers to admitting a student because they're related to alumni of the same institution. Which Trump went to Georgetown?
- scottmcf 6y agoEric Trump.
- csa 6y agoFWIW, I completely agree that she was admitted to Georgetown (and probably Penn, for that matter) for reasons other than academic prowess. I only highlighted her name to demonstrate that celebrity and money can only get you so far. Georgetown is a perfectly fine law school, but it’s a far cry from Harvard or Yale law schools.
- MiroF 6y agoI'm not claiming it's a deterministic process, but it is worth noting that Gtown is the best in DC
- plandis 6y agoLast time I checked it was either Harvard or Yale that admitted about 30% of legacy students but only single digit percentages for regular people — so to some extent you are right.
- MiroF 6y agoThat is for undergrad, and it's worth noting that the average test scores of an admitted legacy student > the average score for all admitted students. Yield calculations have a lot to do with legacy admission rates.
- fountainofage 6y agoAre you saying legacy's have an ABSURDLY higher average test score? Could you share a source on that? To explain a 30% gap in outcomes for two demographics solely by test scores would mean the test score difference is absolutely insane.
- MiroF 6y agoI'll try to find a source for that, it's somewhere in the SFFA trial documents but I'll need to go back and look. But to be clear: I'm not trying to claim that there is no legacy preference and that it can be all explained by test scores. It is definitely a big factor. The only two points I was making is that 1. traditional "legacy" admissions is not necessarily the route that a lot of students without any merit are getting into these top schools - they often have separate pathways for donors and super elite individuals, like Harvard's "z-list." 2. Legacy admissions are because schools know that if they admit more legacy, they will get more donations - but it also has to do with calculations about selectivity. Harvard wants to maximize the chances that the people it admits will choose Harvard so that they don't have to admit more people to fill the class thus raising the admission rate.
- fountainofage 6y agoSomeone said "these schools admit 30% more legacies than peasants" and you said "yeah, but legacies get better test scores than the peasants." And your clarifications really don't address that, and you even seem to back away from it now. Why even make the absurd claim about the intellectual and test-taking superiority of legacies over the peasants if it isn't significant - as you're now claiming?
- rayiner 6y agoLegacy admissions in law schools is much less of a thing than in undergraduate programs because classes are very small, and the school rankings heavily weight LSAT interquartile ranges.