7 ms·
Auschwitz memorial director offers to share Nigerian boy's blasphemy jail term
- ekanes 6y agoWhat a powerful way to send a message.
- vermontdevil 6y agoBlasphemy laws suck
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoSlavoy Zizek has once wisely noticed that each and every nation has its own blasphemy laws. In the Soviet Union a joke about Lenin could ruin your career. In the UK expressing politically incorrect opinion about genders may turn an otherwise successful writer into an outlaw. In Austria expressing doubts about Holocaust will bring you into prison. We all are a bunch of intolerant hypocrites.
- sbmthakur 6y agoNo doubt about being hypocrites. But does one get 10 years for those crimes in UK and Austria?
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoI'd prefer spending 10 years in prison to being excommunicated for life.
- dralley 6y ago> In the UK expressing politically incorrect opinion about genders may turn an otherwise successful writer into an outlaw. "an outlaw", really? This might be one of the most hyperbolic statements I've ever seen. The uproar about JK Rowling is not equivalent to the treatment of "blasphemers" in the Soviet Union, give me a break.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AlexTWithBeard 6y ago> The uproar about JK Rowling is not equivalent to the treatment of "blasphemers" in the Soviet Union Which one do you see as being worse (and why?)
- lostlogin 6y agoMaybe a brief read up on gulags, knowing what got you there and what happened might help you.
- tikhonj 6y agoYou mean comparing the one where a car with its headlights off turns up at your apartment around midnight and you're never seen again to one where you're a billionaire who gets angry comments on Twitter and, maybe, a non-material reduction in ongoing revenue from a work you finished years ago?
- chki 6y agoIs this a serious question? Are you comparing actual executions to the treatment of Rowling on Twitter? You must be trolling.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoOk, now I see where you're coming from. In the original post I was talking about the late (no pun intended) Soviet Union: 1960 onwards. You were not executed for political jokes. You will just be shunned by your friends and won't be offered any decent job and your kids may never get into the college.
- sbmthakur 6y agoIn the Soviet Union, the "blasphemers" were actually tried in a show trial, which sent them to labor camps. All they did was to write satire that did not go well with the state. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinyavsky%E2%80%93Daniel_trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinyavsky%E2%80%93Daniel_trial
- spankalee 6y agoPlease don't equate questioning the Holocaust - a factual historical event - and blasphemy. Regardless of whether you think anti-Holocaust-denying laws are justifiable, even making this comparison seems to put the Holocaust in the same realm of opinion and faith, which is most assuredly is not.
- lixtra 6y agoBut blasphemy laws are justifiable as well. They try to avoid riots on the streets by true believers and also limit the punishment to a well defined point.
- sbmthakur 6y agoConsidering this context, ten year sentence to a thirteen year old boy does not seem justifiable.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoYou mean, imprisoning him for just a couple of years would be perfectly acceptable?
- lixtra 6y agoObviously not. But what if just scolding him leads to riots, your town in ashes and the boy lynched? Not every society is as peaceful as yours [1]. [1] https://news.yahoo.com/another-blogger-hacked-death-bangladesh-061940287.html https://news.yahoo.com/another-blogger-hacked-death-banglade...
- AdrianB1 6y agoI have no doubt about the existence of the Holocaust, but I put the laws in the same bucket of forcing people to think or speak in a way or else. People should be free to think and speak whatever they want, from flat earthers (plain stupid) to Holocaust deniers (ignorant) to religious (no comment) without stupid laws to force them - this is why I love the idea of the USA' First Amendment.
- 6y ago
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> In the UK expressing politically incorrect opinion about genders may turn an otherwise successful writer into an outlaw. An “outlaw” whose latest book went on to top the UK book charts: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/sep/23/jk-rowling-thriller-no-1-transphobia-row-troubled-blood-robert-galbraith https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/sep/23/jk-rowling-thr...
- gedy 6y agoThat you are being downvoted for saying this: QED
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoReligion is one of this weird things that seems to be deeply "built in" into our mind, some kind of atavism. It is much more prevalent than a rational, scientific approach and I can understand people want to defend something they deeply believe in. We are not a tolerant species. Now, as a pure atheist, I am all in favor to ban these laws and pus religion somewhere n the side, together with fairy tales (or psychiatric studies). I also know that this will not happen.
- clairity 6y agothe desire to explain the world is a built-in survival/thrival mechanism. it's not weird so much as fascinating what our brains can conjure.
- chrischen 6y agoThe desire to explain and justify our sins is evil masked as religion.
- f6v 6y agoThe benefits which come from scientific advances aren't distributed equally. My take on this is that for many people religion offers the only justification of suffering on Earth. Otherwise people with low education level and socioeconomic status don't understand why they have to live on 1$ a day.
- auggierose 6y agoSo why are there so many religious people in the US? Are they all living on $1 a day? It probably also explains the current state of the US, as reason and religion usually don't cohabitate too well.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoThe question is “what does religion give them that isn’t given by a more progressive social structure?”
- hprotagonist 6y agoseparation of church and state is vital for the full flourishing of both.
- Nesco 6y agoI don’t think there is a “church” in Islam. Correct me if I am wrong but the imam is only the prayer leader and nothing more. Islam is by definition social (the concept of Ummah) and includes a corpus of laws. And anyway in most Muslim majorities country you couldn’t enforce such a separation anyway. The new attacks in France linked to the republication of depictions of Muhammad by Charlie Hebdo and the violent protest in Sweden after a Danish politicians burned some copies of the Quran shows Thant it can be hard to enforce even with a Muslim minority.
- hprotagonist 6y agoyou can s/religion/church if you want; the intent is the same. I just used the common American synecdoche. Any way you want to slice it, official state sanctioned sectarianism is deadly. Don't do it, that way leads only to pain and degradation. It doesn't matter what family of religions the sect is part of. If full participation in the doings of the state as a citizen requires you to publicly swear to certain religious doctrines as a prerequisite, at least two things happen: 1. religious disagreements are now treasonous threats to the authority of the state that must be met with force, and 2. you cannot trust anyone's affirmation of their beliefs, including your own. Both are extraordinarily corrosive truths to the people who have to perform them, not to mention the state and the religion.
- free_herve 6y agoIt's true, but I would be surprised if the Auschwitz memorial director is really against _all_ blasphemy laws. France just jailed an intellectual, Herve Ryssen, for the contents of his books and documentaries about jews. In the meantime, French political elites, including President Macron, are lauding the re-publication of Charlie Hebdo caricatures about Islam. Some animals are more equal than others... Except for the United States, no country has real freedom of speech, and all countries have taboos that can land you in jail if you write books about certain topics.
- znpy 6y ago> Except for the United States, no country has real freedom of speech Ahem... - https://youtu.be/TIClA57jWmQ https://youtu.be/TIClA57jWmQ - https://youtu.be/xuAAPsiD768 https://youtu.be/xuAAPsiD768 Particularly the second link, the journalist is forbidden from interviewing an inmate. Also he's under special surveillance. Call that "freedom of speech".
- gambiting 6y ago>>Except for the United States, no country has real freedom of speech That's a joke, right? US cosplays at having freedom of speech, the law only protects you from the government, but even that applies selectively - look at the treatment of journalists in the US. No wonder the country is 16th on the freedom of press ranking!
- AdrianB1 6y agoAt least they are trying, most countries have no legal support of any kind for free speech.
- GuB-42 6y agoSure, but it has to be put into context. In countries with a state religion, blasphemy is an attack to the very foundation of that state. Secular countries have similar laws and concepts. It can include hate speech and flag desecration. Some monarchies have lese majeste laws that are similar in nature. In fact, blasphemy and hate speech are very similar. In hate speech, you will, for example, insult the ancestry of your fellow citizens. This is not considered acceptable in a society based on equality, and generally can incite violence, and therefore is illegal in some countries. In blasphemy, you insult the religion of your fellow citizens, this is not acceptable in a society based on that religion and can incite violence, and therefore is illegal is some countries. Other laws that can be related to blasphemy are related to fictional child porn (ex: lolicon). Real child porn is a product of rape, so it is understandably illegal, but lolicon is essentially blasphemy against the sacred "purity" of children. The idea that it can cause distress, incite actual child rape, etc... is the same idea as how blasphemy can cause distress for believers and incite others to not follow the (religious) law. Note, as an atheist, I am against state religions. I am also in favor of freedom of expression over protecting people feelings, especially with such harsh punishment. However, I am not Nigerian, I don't know their culture, so I won't give them lessons when it comes to their internal affairs. I can only disagree.
- riffraff 6y ago> he and 119 other volunteers I appreciate the sentiment, but there's some difference between splitting 13 years of jail in 2 vs splitting it in 120, which make this offer a lot less impressive, even if it made any sense from a legal point of view. Still, it's a gesture that can be commended, but the title is a bit misleading.
- lixtra 6y agoOf course it’s just a gesture. No one would like a judicial system were you can outsource the punishment. It’s all about pointing out how wrong it is to send a 13-year old to jail for blasphemy.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> Of course it’s just a gesture. Yes and no. It'a a gesture because it's hard to conceive the government would agree. However, in the extremely unlikely case they agree, it's unthinkable the volunteers could chicken out. They must have already fought the battle in their minds, imagining the consequences of a month spend in a jail in Africa - if they are not stupid they know everything could happen. Personally I admire these people a lot.
- mosselman 6y agoThe offer is coming from the director, so he _is_ offering. 'Misleading' makes it sound like the title is a lie, which it isn't. You just misunderstood. Also, the offer coming from 120 people is a lot more powerful than just 1 person. It signals that many people find this an unjust ruling, rather than just 1 person, and are willing to go all the way to Nigeria for it and spend a month in what is probably hell on earth, especially for westerners.
- RobLach 6y agoWell... they misunderstood because it's misleading. The burden of clarity is not on the reader.
- 6y ago
- sbmthakur 6y agoThe Sharia court's verdict can be challenged at Nigeria's Supreme court, right?
- davehcker 6y agoI would think so. Fatwas i.e. the Sharia rulings are legally non-binding (https://en.unesco.org/courier/2017-april-june/what-sharia-not https://en.unesco.org/courier/2017-april-june/what-sharia-no...). 'Secularism, Sovereignty, Indeterminacy: Is Egypt a Secular or a Religious State?' by H Ali Agrama is a very interesting anthropological account of Sharia law for those interested in exploring the issue further.
- tomc1985 6y agoWhat is the connection between the Auschwitz memorial director and this Nigerian boy? Why is he (and these 119 others) trying to take a bullet for him, so to speak?
- cjohnson318 6y ago> As the director of a memorial to a place “where children were imprisoned and murdered, I cannot remain indifferent to this disgraceful sentence for humanity,” he said in the letter to President Muhammadu Buhari, posted on the Memorial’s Twitter account.
- tikhonj 6y agoWhy does there have to be a connection? It's a fundamentally unjust law, so people are trying to do two things in response: 1. Help ameliorate the punishment for a less unjust outcome in this specific case. 2. Take a symbolic action to protest blasphemy laws as a whole. No need to look for hidden motivations!
- nix23 6y agoJust imagine being a God and you think it's oke for your minions to trow a 13 yo in Jail for 10 years...must be a really grumpy and not really self-assured "God"
- HenryBemis 6y agoJust imagine being a god and giving cancer to little kids, allowing kids to be abused, raped, murdered, allow women to be beaten and raped by men, allow mankind to murder en mass other species.. The above is why I believe that there is no god, of course people may believe whatever they chose to, but in REALITY no such thing exists. Also it is the perpetual question, if there is "one true God", who is it? My god? Your god? Zeus? Some other got of some other species on some other planet in some other galaxy? (The Delta Quadrant?) The main problem is not the idea of God (imho god = love) The main problem is the people who self define/proclaim as the god's chosen people on earth.
- halflings 6y ago> The main problem is not the idea of God (imho god = love) Well there goes your problem, you're countering something that these religions don't claim in the first place: None of the Abrahamic religions (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, etc.) claim that God is pure love, butterflies and spreads happiness on earth. Their scriptures explicitly talk about how life on earth is (also) filled with pain, disease and man-created problems. I'm not sure why this criticism ("What kind of god gives kids cancer") on religion is so common in Western countries... it's a giant strawman that a simple question to a believer of such religion would dispell.
- HenryBemis 6y agoLet me reiterate. There is no god. If there is one and we have evidence of Her, let her show herself and lay a lightning on me. Oh wait, there is no god. Now then, most gods (or the fanatics that self proclaim that they are the chosen ones on this earth) tend to write books etc that either speak of love or of hate. I am the kind of stupid that I prefer the love over the hate. We can find a million reasons to hate one another. I prefer to go with the one million reasons to love one another. Thus my god = love. Either way, this discussion is moot since there is no god :)
- DayDollar 6y agoreligion, is and was foremost, always a way to end a conversation, a debate, by declaring the topic holy and decided. Nobody could decide it, not your children, nor the woman or slaves, and especially not apostates or other religions. As such it can not be part of any civil democratic society, which by its very nature demands that all but the most human basic rights be debat- and negotiable. You can not declare something sacrosanct, cut the fabric of society without a reason, and expect perferable treatment by those whose society you trampled over because you threatened civil war. Écrasez l'infâme
- rich_sasha 6y agoWith respect, it’s a mischaracterisation and a huge overreach. It’s like saying democracy is a disaster because it leads to Trump, or the next populist.
- Nesco 6y agoThe separation between the sacred and the profane predates religion and persist even in atheism. Topics related to human life are broadly forbidden to economic activities for example.
- yumraj 6y agoPakistan has similar blasphemy laws, where it seems it is commonly used to resolve personal vendettas against non-muslims. A lot of attention, and rightly so, is paid to racial and other kinds of discrimination. But nothing has caused more harm and more deaths and suffering over the centuries than religion. I consider religion to be the worst human invention of all times. Whether there is God or Gods or not, can be debated for ever, but religion is a useless, evil and malicious construct.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoPerhaps religion is just another place where various forms of moral evil manifest as a result of human nature? You’re almost enacting your religion by talking so categorically.
- raincom 6y agoTherein lies the problem: in this case, you consider Islam a human product; however, muslims don't see it that way: Islam is Allah's revelation. When people explain religion as a human product, they are NOT explaining anything at all. In other words, these so-called scientists selling religion as a human product(necessity) don't understand believers at all. One of the ways Orientalists ridiculed muslims to call them as Mohammeden (or Mohammadiyas). Muslims don't see it that way. Also look at how Sunnis ridicule another sect by calling them Ahmediyas.
- yumraj 6y agoYou make a fair point. BTW, I was not pointing to any single religion, I was talking in abstract since I believe that religion has been misused to cause much human misery. It’s just sad is all.
- sbmthakur 6y ago> But nothing has caused more harm and more deaths and suffering over the centuries than religion. Colonialism and racism have also caused a significant number of deaths. > I consider religion to be the worst human invention of all times. I somewhat differ. I am no historian but religion does add some discipline to a society which is in a complete mess. In today's times, as long as religion is at the periphery of one's life, it seems fine. The problem arises when religion becomes life.
- rich_sasha 6y agoThere is a lot on this thread of the usual “just look how nasty religion is”. I think basically you can cherry pick facts about democracy and reach the same conclusions. Just look what western democracies did in the Middle East, what’s happening (and who is the president) in America. It’s an instrument of oppression and nothing else, just a way for the powerful to amass power. It’s misguided and painfully selective. Sure, plenty of people use religion / democracy for nefarious goals. This does not even commence to assess their wider utility. The answer to improving both is usually education. It’s not religious people as such who prosecute blasphemers, it is uneducated people, or those looking to whip up their support.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoThe Western civilization has several problems, but the freedom of speech is incomparable. The maximum punishment you can get for not embracing diversity, LGBT rights and so on is getting fired and public ostracism. I haven't heard of anyone jailed for saying that there is a distribution of certain traits between the two sexes and so on.
- rich_sasha 6y agoI’m not in any way supporting the sentence, or anything about it. It’s the extension of “hence all religion is evil” is wrong. You could say, hey look democracies wage all these nasty wars. Killing people is the ultimate bad thing, and North Korea isn’t doing it, so communism must be better. It’s not, and yes killing people is bad.
- Nesco 6y agoWhat is going here is both really funny and typical of HN groupthink. Every one is criticising blasphemy laws but virtually no one even dared to mention the legal corpus which justifies it here: Islam, referring to ‘religions’ or generally to ‘blasphemy laws’. It’s funny to that people here will demand that Nigerian authorities do something putting their physical safety and civil peace at risk but are afraid to look bad from a SF-centric perspective and be downvoted here.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> What is going here is both really funny and typical of HN groupthink. Every one is criticising blasphemy laws but virtually no one even dared to mention the legal corpus which justifies it here: Islam, referring to ‘religions’ or generally to ‘blasphemy laws’. It's not just political correctness and being afraid to single out Islam. Christianity had many similar problems in the past. Even now, all Judeo-Christian religions are based on a book that would be considered an extreme example of hate speech if written now. Indian traditions have the caste system. Buddhism is in a better position but even there have been cases of abusing it. So if you just limit your criticism to Islam, it's not entirely fair, even though many consider it the most problematic religion in the world at this point of our history.
- Nesco 6y agoI am a lifelong atheist so don’t expect me to defend (even modern) Hinduism and Christianity. They have their own flaws that are also deep. I was just pointing out no one dared to use the word Islam - so at this point it was clear for me it was for political correctness - and while being afraid for so little they are hypocritically saying the Nigerian authorities should prevent that. A move that could actually trigger deadly riots or attacks. However thanks for actually replying and stating your disagreement instead of acting like those who predictably silently downvoted.