3 ms·
If the new owner is imposter trying to be the old owner, it would be identity theft and fraud. If it's just giving the handle to someone else there is nothing.
by nabla9 6y ago
If the new owner is imposter trying to be the old owner, it would be identity theft and fraud. If it's just giving the handle to someone else there is nothing. If you don't pay for a account, you don't usually own it unless there is something I'm missing.
If you want to own your identity in the internet, get a website you own and don't rely on shady social-media networks that give you something free.
- zamadatix 6y agoIt's remarkably hard to actually "own" anything on the internet. The act of paying for something or not does not dictate what's your property - ASNs are leased, IPs are leased, domains are leased, connections are leased and you'll need to either pay or use someone else's to host something on the internet. The closest you could come is legacy IPv4 space and not rely on traditional infrastructure such as DNS. Most registrars have decent trademark policies but again it's the internet. Just because you have a trademark in your country doesn't mean someone else doesn't elsewhere or that the registrar is going to care 5 years from now when the ToS change on renewal. If you want to be securely verifiable on the internet you're better off being searchable and signing your content. The hard part is finding people that care enough to verify who you are in a decentralized manner for that to matter though.
- skybrian 6y agoI wonder how Let's Encrypt and other certificate authorities handle disputes over domain transfers?
- zamadatix 6y agoA DV (domain validation) certificate shows the content came from the person in control of the domain (i.e. can change DNS records or change the server content) not that the person in control of the domain is "who it should be". With that in mind the person who can show current control is able to generate new certificates and issue revocations for old ones. OV (Organization Validation) and EV (Extended Validation) certificates get into the "is it who they say to be" but Let's Encrypt won't issue those. What all getting validated entails is a bit more in depth for each of these and so is the revocation. The ultimate protection in cases like domain transfers is limited lifetimes though. Gone are the days where the last guy likely had a 2+ year cert for the domain. Let's Encrypt is 90 days max and it's increasingly hard to get even 1 year from traditional players.
- jstanley 6y agoInterestingly you can "own" an Onion address for a Tor hidden service quite easily. You know the private key and nobody else does, so nobody can take your address away from you.
- zamadatix 6y agoYeah .onion addresses fall into the bucket of signing things (which works) and trying to get people to care enough to use it (which usually doesn't outside of extreme niches). An interesting note on Onion addresses though is the top supercomputer is already at the level to be able to brute force collisions for any onion address in a little over a decade. I expect within about 10 years when this becomes a more imminent problem names will become longer.
- SpelingBeeChamp 6y agoIf it's known that you are the owner a court can theoretically take it away from you. (Or at least jail you if you don't hand it over.)
- jstanley 6y agoPerfect. That's the same level of ownership that you have over anything physical, which is the level of ownership that the comment I was replying to was saying is hard to achieve on the Internet.
- cnst 6y agoJust because a fee is due annually doesn't mean you don't "own" whatever it is that you "lease". In the real world, you still have to pay taxes and HOA fees on real estate property that you own; plus, have to put up (or finance) a huge deposit in order to "own" it. Same goes for any other large property like cars. You're talking about trademarks, but trademarks themselves often require renewal every 10 years, where you have to continue paying a renewal fee in order to continue to "own" it.
- thw0rted 6y agoThe question of ownership comes down to whether you have a right to that renewal. As long as you keep paying the fee, you have a right to continue using that trademark, unless legal action is taken to challenge it. Can you say that about your Twitter handle? Do you have a legal right to keep using that Twitter account, and if Twitter tries to give the account to someone else, can you get an injunction preventing them from doing so? (Now, same question but for your FB, Instagram, email, domain name, etc etc.)
- humaniania 6y agoPlatforms charging $1/year for a social media account seems like a reasonable solution to a number of problems.
- nix23 6y agoThat's really not a bad idea like you own a domain you own your federated account on a Platform, you can self host it or put it into their cloud (costs 1$/mtn)...yes yes i know mastodon or diaspora but facebook and twitter should be forced to go a "federated" way, with that they could rip out most if not all of their problems they actually have, and you have all the rights you want (if you host it).