3 ms·
I don't think the "theft" of the username would break any kind of law, as this was a company decision (since it done by an employee) and the username was never
by Nextgrid 6y ago
I don't think the "theft" of the username would break any kind of law, as this was a company decision (since it done by an employee) and the username was never your property anyway. I'm assuming that employee definitely violated some internal policies, but nothing from a legal point of view.
The only recourse I can see from a legal point of view is that they seem to have handed over the entire account (as the followers seem to have been carried over), which contains private data including DMs, stories, archives of deleted pictures, etc. Given that the original owner of the account is based in the UK, GDPR should apply. I wonder if people he talked to via DMs (as well as those with private accounts who granted his account access) would also have a case, since Facebook's actions have disclosed private conversations & contents of private accounts) to an unauthorized person.
I don't have a Twitter account but if someone could suggest this person to complain to their local data protection regulator (the ICO in case of the UK) that would be great.
- tdhz77 6y agoI wonder if the justice department would go after somebody who overtook Donald Trump or other high profile official. They might make the case based off national security as the legal rational. But, otherwise I do agree with your point.
- Scene_Cast2 6y agoI think the OP's point was that there _should_ be a law, and that the current legislative framework is insufficient.
- ABCLAW 6y agoThere are plenty of laws that would give rise to remedies in this situation. Contrary to popular belief, tech companies aren't invincible to lawsuits. Neither is the guy operating the stolen account. The issue isn't whether or not there are theories under tort or contract that would cover remedies here - they would. The issue is whether or not this is something that's economically feasible to get in front of the courts - it's not.
- drivebycomment 6y agoOP is simply ignorant. There are many laws that would make account take-over an illegal activity - it would depend on what exactly the perpetrator did, but wire fraud and criminal conspiracy most likely apply. If the OP's point is about consumer protection in case of any dispute with online provider, there's maybe a tiny bit of truth, but that's not a criminal law. If the OP's point is whether there's sufficient enforcement and investigation for account take-over, that would be correct, but it's not clear if the society would be better off spending large resources on investigating those when there are much more serious crimes not being investigated sufficiently and when companies are generally doing reasonable attempts at providing protection.
- vsareto 6y ago>and the username was never your property anyway Usernames can be associated to content and brands that have been made on other platforms. I wouldn't be so sure about this.
- otterley 6y agoThere is absolutely a legal theory, and that is fraud. If you claim to be someone you are not, and someone relies on your false claim to their detriment, you are liable.
- Nextgrid 6y agoMy point was whether Facebook itself committed a crime and whether the account holder had any recourse against Facebook. To me it doesn't look like it - the username remains the property of FB and they are free to do anything they want with it.
- otterley 6y agoIt might take an open-minded judge to accept this, but attorneys often fall back to common-law negligence when there are no stronger legal theories to rely on. All the elements of negligence seem to be here, except probably for duty of care. A judge would have to find that Facebook owes a duty of care to its users to protect the integrity of its identities, and that Facebook breached that duty. I can foresee Facebook and other information service providers fighting vigorously against such a legal conclusion, but maybe it's just the kind of law we need.
- klyrs 6y agoIf somebody hijacks your account, they get access to all your DMs and other private info. Are you claiming that all that is fb's property, too?
- owenmarshall 6y agoFraud seems a stretch. Maybe if you used your handle for commerce and someone stole it & attempted to sell the same product. It doesn’t strike me as litigation you’d be likely to win.
- otterley 6y ago> Maybe if you used your handle for commerce and someone stole it & attempted to sell the same product. That would be an example -- but certainly not the only imaginable one -- of reliance and detriment, both of which are necessary elements of fraud.
- pmontra 6y agoIt's not only the user name. It's the photos, chats, etc. Of course one should backup the photos outside Instagram or any other service but I have no idea if Instagram allows that. For Whatsapp on Android it's as easy as syncing the pictures folder on the phone to my computer. Then I backup them with all my other files.