3 ms·
Has aged better? Most don't listen to Sgt. Peppers today, but tons still listen to the Beatles, including younger audiences. How many comparatively listen to th
by coldtea 6y ago
Has aged better? Most don't listen to Sgt. Peppers today, but tons still listen to the Beatles, including younger audiences. How many comparatively listen to the Pet Sounds or the Beach Boys?
And how "not dated" it is? It's chock full of late-60s pop sounds and harmonies, which is even more dated than the everything goes/psychedelia/world influences of Sgt. Pepper.
The Pet Sounds is mostly something hipsters started to mention around 2000 or so as better than Sergent Pepper to appear "edgier" and "more informed" than those giving the conventional answer.
- tptacek 6y agoThe question isn't whether the Beatles or the Beach Boys have aged better. Obviously, the Beatles have. But Pet Sounds has aged better than Sgt. Pepper's, was more influential (it's part of the reason there is a Sgt. Pepper's), and its songs have aged better. Apart from "Lovely Rita", is there are song on Sgt. Pepper's that you'd go back to deliberately today? "Wouldn't It Be Nice", "God Only Knows", "I Know There's An Answer", and even "Sloop John B" --- timeless. Also, "Sloop John B" is the song that runs through my head every time I think about having left a startup. If the question is, what's the better band? The answer is obvious: the Beatles are better than the Beach Boys. And I'd listen to Revolver before I'd listen to either of the two albums we're arguing about. But between those two albums? It has to be Pet Sounds.