3 ms·
> "Data from my own lab suggests that the cortical networks in the human brain that allow us to attribute consciousness to others overlap extensively with the n
by 082349872349872 6y ago
> "Data from my own lab suggests that the cortical networks in the human brain that allow us to attribute consciousness to others overlap extensively with the networks that construct our own sense of consciousness."
That agrees with my guess that attribution to others came first, and our own is an accidental byproduct: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23475069 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23475069
- tsimionescu 6y agoFirst of all, I would be wary of any solid link between brain activity and high-level brain functions like consciousness. The rigour of some neuroscience experiments has been highly critized in the past [0]. Secondly, even if the finding is correct, it gives no information about which function came first. It is consistent both with the idea that 'consciousness is empathy/actor modeling applied to the self' and with the idea that 'empathy/actor modelling is consciousness applied to other actors'. In general, it is very hard to guess evolutionary timeliness from present structures where we have no idea of the genetic encoding of the current structures. [0] for example this study criticizing certain careless fMRI methods https://teenspecies.github.io/pdfs/NeuralCorrelates.pdf https://teenspecies.github.io/pdfs/NeuralCorrelates.pdf
- sooheon 6y agoInteresting theory, the article largely agrees with you. I'll add that "others" can include future selves, in which case the evolutionary benefit becomes clear. The capacity to model one's current state is recursive and superfluous, but the ability to model one's future potential states is essential to planning.