3 ms·
The cores I compare the smaller RV cores to (the ARMv*-M cores) don't seem to have a popcount instruction either, not even in their new Helium vector ISA. If i
by monocasa 6y ago
The cores I compare the smaller RV cores to (the ARMv*-M cores) don't seem to have a popcount instruction either, not even in their new Helium vector ISA.
If it's a deficiency at that gate count, it's one RV doesn't have to compete on it seems.
- ncmncm 6y agoMeaning, it offers no advantage over them? How does that make it better able to compete? When you are coming from far behind, as RV is, you need to be better just to pull even.
- monocasa 6y agoI'm saying the lack of a popcount isn't a deficiency, considering that it's competitors don't have it either. And given the huge amount of work ARM put into the Helium ISA, I wouldn't be surprised if the instruction simply didn't make sense at that gate count anyway. For cores that go down to 12K gates like a CortexM0 or the smaller RV32E cores, popcount in the ALU is a distinct non zero cost. And yeah, you for sure need to be better to compete. Zero fees is a large chunk of what'll get you there for these tiny cores. When you're being compared on borderline ascetic area efficiency, adding features works against you.