7 ms·
This article is from 2014, right now my annoyance is more all these apps with low self esteem. Always this stupid question "do you like this app" and then redi
by GekkePrutser 6y ago
This article is from 2014, right now my annoyance is more all these apps with low self esteem.
Always this stupid question "do you like this app" and then redirecting me to the play store to vote if I say yes or the support site when I say no. And to make matters worse they keep doing it every few days. Once is passable, over and over is NOT.
I've started to give 1-star reviews to these apps. So sick of this behaviour. Especially many of Microsoft's corporate apps do this (like outlook or teams) and most people download these because they need them, not because of some rating.
edit: I mean I do the 1-star thing with the apps which keep asking. If they ask once I just don't do the review (If I really love the app I would have left a 5-star review anyway). But once it comes up again I do this.
- URSpider94 6y agoApp developers do this because, gasp, it works. Filtering reviews this way absolutely, quantitatively, repeatedly boosts app ratings, and apps with higher ratings get more downloads. Don’t expect developers to stop doing this just because it annoys you.
- ulucs 6y agoUnless enough people start giving one stars because of such filtering :^)
- tomc1985 6y agoWe should not be justifying shitty negative externalities because "they help the developer". We should be destroying existing systems and reforming them so that everyone is happy
- sdkjfnnjjj 6y agoWhat mechanism would you propose?
- tomc1985 6y agoRatings systems have been gamed to meaninglessness. First stop would probably be removing those. I realize that creates more discovery problems, but I think that can be ameliorated somewhat by making more use of professional reviewers and app-store integrations with publications like Wirecutter or Consumer Reports.
- sdkjfnnjjj 6y agoTrue that rating systems have been hacked. Maybe it really boils down to only following reviews from people you trust, which could be selected professional reviewers.
- bonestormii_ 6y agoInterestingly, I'm pretty sure apps that drive traffic to other apps are generally not permitted on the app store, per some huge HN thread recently featuring a letter to Tim Cook from the developer of such an app who got removed. I feel like the internet-pro's work around to validating quality of anything, strangely, is to find a reddit thread where people seem to discuss it meaningfully and logically.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoSubreddit trick is super useful. Also for avoiding disinformation, which is a problem in any topic that applies to the general population, because these are thoroughly SEO-saturated by content marketing scoundrels. So usually one of the first things I do is search "<topic of interest> site:reddit.com", look for dedicated subreddits, and browse the top posts and the subreddit wiki. More often than not, there's a lot of solid community knowledge collected there. Circling back to the topic of apps and ratings, I pretty much never use the app store for product discovery. If I install an app, it's because I knew about it from elsewhere. May be a professional reviewer, may be a friend, or may be a random poster on HN. Basically, it must be a human who I can be confident isn't trying to deceive me.
- tomc1985 6y ago
- rpeden 6y agoI'm not sure that making everyone happy is an achievable goal. I enjoy rating and reviewing apps, and I don't mind when apps ask me to do it. So your proposed solution would make me unhappy vs. the status quo.
- mortehu 6y agoMaybe a platform will ban or penalize this behavior if we complain about it loudly enough. It is or will become a Nash equilibrium that can only be resolved by Apple and Google. Once all apps do this, the app developers are back to where they started, but users are worse off.
- colejohnson66 6y agoIIRC Apple requires apps to use Apple’s method to ask users to review. And they respect the “don’t bother me” answer.
- the__alchemist 6y agoI'll join in on punishing these techniques, in an effort to make it not work.
- ufmace 6y agoI think he did say - it's one thing to do it once. It gets really annoying when apps do it over and over again.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoI expect app stores to ban apps (or at least ban reviews) that manipulate reviews.
- cortesoft 6y agoRight, and if we can convince more people to give 1 star reviews when apps do this, then maybe it will stop working and developers will stop doing it. Also, we expect people to stop a lot of things that 'work' because people are annoyed. Email SPAM worked well enough for people to keep doing it, so we passed laws to restrict it.
- awillen 6y agoYou've clearly never been on the other side of things... ratings help app developers get reviews, which is important for their business. It's a hard place to be, and they're doing something that works, even if it is kind of annoying. For Microsoft apps, sure, rate whatever you want, but if you're giving 1-star reviews to apps made by smaller developers just because they're asking for a review of their app, you're just a jerk.
- ulucs 6y agoIt's more because of the dark pattern of blocking possible bad reviews by redirecting them to support.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoWell usually bad reviews do include a lot of details. I also often see support from the company actually responding to users, and these issues getting resolved and the ratings modified. This is one way where that process works well.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoWell it's more than "kind of" annoying. Just to clarify: I'm only doing the 1-star review on apps that ask more than once. But tbh I haven't seen it in apps made by smaller developers. Only in ones by big companies. The ones made by smaller devs usually care much more about their user experience, if they ask it at all they ask it once only and not over and over again like Microsoft does. Reddit's app is another big one there but obviously they don't give anything about their users, they are super annoying anyway (like constantly trying to force you to use the app if you view reddit in a webbrowser on a phone). But the ones I use from smaller devs are usually FOSS so they don't care about their ratings at all, as they don't make money anyway. And I'm much more likely to support these with good ratings anyway. I don't care about Microsoft's business :) Still, I think it is bad practice. If I love an app I give it a good rating anyway. If you do it, please don't make it a yes/no. But also include a "stop bothering me" button :)
- 6y ago
- ziml77 6y agoI don't know how much teeth the Play Store rules have, but I wish it was against the ToS to display things like that. Or at least disallow having an option that expresses dissatisfaction while bypassing the Play Store review system, but sending any positive response along to it to boost the application's rating.
- jrockway 6y agoI think Apple actually has an API for this flow. So it's not against the ToS, it's actually something they encourage! (Here's the API: https://developer.apple.com/app-store/ratings-and-reviews/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store/ratings-and-reviews/) This goes to show one of the big problems with app stores. Apple wants to have a bunch of apps that all have 5 star reviews, so you think everyone using an iPhone is happy and that all the apps are Just Great. You joined a club when buying an iPhone and everyone here is just so happy and would never ever think of leaving! Since they control the OS and manually approve every app, they can make sure that the apps go out of their way to encourage people to think the club is perfect. The fact that 99% of reviews are completely misleading is a problem for another day. (They probably filter out reviews like "1 star: asks me 3 times a day if I like the app." Amazon sure does. I have posted a number of thoughtful 1 star reviews on Amazon for completely flawed products, including objective data showing the flaws... and they just got removed instantly. Conflict of interest up the wazoo.) Somehow I don't think this model would work too well if there were a competing app store with honest reviews. (Not that I think you can ever have honest reviews. Everything about reviews, not only in the mobile app category, is basically completely flawed.)
- ziml77 6y agoWhat you're showing is exactly a case that I think is okay as long as it's not spammed to the user. Any rating that's chosen through this will go directly to the App Store listing instead of being filtered out by redirecting the user to some feedback form.
- colejohnson66 6y ago> This goes to show one of the big problems with app stores. Apple wants to have a bunch of apps that all have 5 star reviews, so you think everyone using an iPhone is happy and that all the apps are Just Great. OR Apple wants to improve user experience by requiring developers to use something that respects the “don’t bother me” answer. Apple is not the best, but not everything is a conspiracy
- jakub_g 6y agoIt's a really important thing for the apps because by default only unhappy people go to Play Store and give 1 star. Then it looks like your app is crap and the competitors are way better. In prev job, we had few ratings of our app, and avg. of 3.5. After adding the question, we got thousands of 5 stars and went to avg. 4.7 in a few months. Of course the app should give you "I don't care" option, and store your answer to not repeat the question.
- Dahoon 6y agoI always answer yes and give a one star rating. An app that tries to game the system (and likely breaks the stores rules) deserve it.
- jakub_g 6y agoYou see two competing apps. One is rated 3.5 and has 100 reviews, another is rated 4.4 and has 10000 reviews. Which one do you install?
- devilduck 6y agoYou try them both and decide for yourself what you like.
- badsectoracula 6y agoThe second one, of course, but that should come from genuine reviews, not gaming the system because when you do that then it devalues the system for everyone.
- IgorPartola 6y agoBoth. Say I’m looking for a budget app. They can be very different and work very differently. Also given that it is still possible to buy reviews, how much do you really trust them. I would even look at the app that had 1000 one star reviews out of curiosity. I mean Apple’s own apps often have a 2 star average and they are the ones I use all the time. I think I’m going to adopt the strategy of leaving a 1 star review saying “the app prompted me to review it before I got to use it”.
- stevula 6y agoUsually if you say you don’t like the app it won’t direct you to the App Store but will just ask for feedback within the app. It’s much less disruptive than saying “yes” and getting switched to the App Store.
- quickthrower2 6y agoBack in '14 I did a ASO course "App Store Optimisation" that pushed this technique. It was one of the things I didn't do because it seemed too cringy for me.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIt's interesting because soliciting ad clicks will get your account banned (and this is enforced very heavy handedly), but soliciting biased reviews is encouraged.
- jlis 6y agoMost of the times you get so see the rating/review dialogs when the app was updated. The App Store only shows reviews for the latest release of the app by default, not for all versions combined like the Play Store does. So if you update your iOS app, there are no reviews displayed in the App Store for your app. To get some reviews for the new version, people show you the rating/review dialog. At least that's how it was done at LOVOO (disclosure: I worked there). With every new version you'd see the review/rating dialog again.