4 ms·
"What's Going On" in first place? Yeah, I don't see it. It's good, but it wasn't THAT good even when it came out. Whereas Sgt Pepper was heraled and recognized
by coldtea 6y ago
"What's Going On" in first place? Yeah, I don't see it. It's good, but it wasn't THAT good even when it came out. Whereas Sgt Pepper was heraled and recognized as such from day one -- and for the next decades. And number 3 is Joni Mitchel's Blue?
This is more about pandering to 2020 ideologies and taste than about a somewhat objective album ranking.
- smnrchrds 6y ago> objective album ranking That's gotta be an oxymoron.
- coldtea 6y agoGetting close to making that oxymoron a reality is the whole goal of any album ranking. Else just as well don't rank anything, and just say "this is a random assembly of random tastes".
- CydeWeys 6y agoIt's not remotely a random collection though, it's a ranking of the albums actually considered "the best" by the people compiling the list. So yes, while saying "best" isn't objective, it's still completely different from "random". A "best" list still has lots of uses for lots of people (even if not for you), whereas "random" doesn't.
- samdjstephens 6y agoIs there such a thing as an objective album ranking? Especially when you consider the shifting landscape of music over time. Actually forget the shifting landscape of music, consider the shifting landscape of people - theres been significant generational change since 2003, doesn't it make sense that albums move up and down the ranking as their relevance increases or decreases? It doesn't surprise me at all that Marvin Gaye would have gone up the ranking. edit: I think it's also worth asking the question of what role race played in the degree to which an artist or group was heralded "at the time".
- coldtea 6y ago>Is there such a thing as an objective album ranking? No, but there's such thing as a "somewhat objective album ranking". >Actually forget the shifting landscape of music, consider the shifting landscape of people - theres been significant generational change since 2003, doesn't it make sense that albums move up and down the ranking as their relevance increases or decreases? Not when it hasn't change that much for 3 decades prior... >It doesn't surprise me at all that Marvin Gaye would have gone up the ranking. As if Marvin Gaye represents some new taste/genre? It's as old or older as a lot of the stuff it went above in ranking. And it's not like 2020 sensibilities are somehow closer to Joni Mitchel's Blue suddenly over, say, Velvet Underground (which, iirc, got dropped in ranking).
- CydeWeys 6y ago> No, but there's such thing as a "somewhat objective album ranking". Is there? Can you expand on the methodology? All the somewhat objective ranking methodologies I can think of rely on data sources such as top-sellers lists, which would result in not a ranking of best albums but rather of highest selling ones. "Best" is inherently subjective in my estimation. About the best you can do for that is figure out which albums the largest number of people would consider best (but now you have absolutely massive familiarity and sampling biases to contend with).
- geocanuck 6y agobeauty has levels of objectivity. there is partial subjectivity in aesthetic judgement. hence "somewhat objective"
- CydeWeys 6y ago> beauty has levels of objectivity. Can you make this more concrete for me? What are the concrete levels of objectivity as applied to the judgment of quality of musical albums? The thing about objectivity is you can define what you're talking about very precisely, i.e. "This angle on this triangle is 72 degrees" is an objective statement (subject only to measurement error). I'd love to see some similar statements about how we can make objective statements on the beauty or quality of music.
- InitialLastName 6y agoTo be more sympathetic, perhaps this is more representative of 2020's music critics' demographic shifts, evaluation of pop music history, and changes in the way music is presented to listeners? Keep in mind that voters are likely to overweight the music they were exposed to as teenagers and young adults (and the influences of that music), and that in the last 40 years pop music has become much less racially segregated than it was in the 30s-70s. In the time since the 2003 edition, there's been a full generation of turnover; the largely white, rock-oriented baby boomers who ran and were the target audience of Rolling Stone from its founding have largely retired, to be replaced by millennials who, whether or not they are more diverse, had more exposure as teenagers to music by black people that was once relegated to the R&B charts. To use the albums you listed (which, conveniently, came out within 5 years of each other), of course a reduction in rock's mindshare among critics is going to hurt Sgt Pepper the most. Looking at the Hot 100 today [0] (9-26-2020), and ignoring the electronic music whose forebears haven't had long enough to filter into cultural influence, I see a lot of confessional singer-songwriters and a lot of R&B. TL;DR: Baby Boomers have lost influence at Rolling Stone in the last 20 years, so the rankings have shifted to meet the tastes and influences of a generation of music critics that were exposed to a lot more music by black people as teenagers. [0] https://www.billboard.com/charts/hot-100 https://www.billboard.com/charts/hot-100
- musicale 6y ago> a generation of music critics that were exposed to a lot more music by black people as teenagers. unlike those who grew up with blues, jazz, r&b, rock (and roll), gospel, doo-wop, calypso, soul, motown, reggae, disco, rap, club/dance, techno, pop, hip hop, etc.
- InitialLastName 6y agoI'm not saying those genres didn't exist, I'm saying that when the baby boomers were growing up, music was MUCH more segregated than it is now. White people in white areas were marketed music for white people, and v.v. for black people. For a long time, much of the business of Nashville was recording two versions of every song, one by a black person for a black audience, one by a white person. Hell, both Elvis and the British invasion were underlined by white people covering classic blues songs (and selling it to white audiences who didn't know they were covers).
- npunt 6y agoHave you listened to Sgt Pepper recently? Certainly great in its time and groundbreaking, but musically it's not aged that well and its songs are not particularly relevant. I say this has a huge Beatles fan who can sing just about every song. What's Going On both is both great musically and has remained completely relevant - its passed the test of time far better.
- o0-0o 6y agoSgt Pepper is a concept album about a fake band, that has nothing to do with reality or the times. If you look at through that lens you are missing the point entirely.
- tptacek 6y agoPet Sounds is also the more important of the two seminal rock albums, has aged better, and is actually the best Beach Boys album, as opposed to Sgt. Peppers, which isn't the Beatles best.
- npunt 6y agoAgree that Pet Sounds was very influential especially in music production, and has some great tracks. To my ears though it sounds incredibly dated, like a time capsule of sappy 60s teenage pop or music you'd hear on a TV show from the 60s-70s. There's something about the Beach Boys - especially their vocals - that fail to transcend that era. I guess the test for me is what the listening experience is like. Certain musical sounds / conventions / lyrics tend to be rooted in their era, like Beach Boys 'ba- ba ba ba ba-', falsetto harmonies, instruments & production method, etc. Altogether they're pretty distracting make it harder to enjoy the many good parts.
- kimi 6y agoDefinitely agree. I tried multiple times to "get" Pet sounds, it's not bad, but the Beatles did run circles around it.
- coldtea 6y ago
- ponker 6y agoThe real reason for the updates to the list are to get clicks. If the list doesn’t change at all, there’s no news. If it’s a completely different list every time, there’s no legitimacy. The list is tweaked by the amount that makes it a news story with a healthy and spirited debate on Twitter.
- dublin 6y agoWorse, "What's Going On" (a good, but not #1-worthy album, for sure) rose to number one, while the remarkably complex and innovative "Getz/Gilberto", which influence myriad other performers, dropped off the list entirely.