5 ms·
> For their part, many crypto users are angry with the IRS’s guidance, which treats bitcoin, ether and their kin as property rather than currency. So if a crypt
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> For their part, many crypto users are angry with the IRS’s guidance, which treats bitcoin, ether and their kin as property rather than currency. So if a crypto holder uses it to buy something or exchanges one cryptocurrency for another, there’s usually a capital gain or loss to report on the tax return.
I was confused by this statement, as my understanding is that treating it as a currency would result in worse tax consequences.
- vmception 6y agoCan you elaborate? Currency treatment wouldn’t make sense for most digital assets but what way would the tax treatment be worse than unclassified property?
- sokoloff 6y agoIf I buy Euros with USD and then buy a meal or hotel stay with those Euros, I don’t pay any US tax (and importantly, I have no IRS paperwork obligation) regardless of whether the Euro-USD exchange rate changed on the meantime. The same is not true if you replace Euro with Bitcoin above.
- vmception 6y agoThat doesn’t answer the question, that was an unnecessary example about the status quo, how would it be worse if the IRS treated them like currency because you just wrote an example showing how it would be better. Let’s just wait for the person I originally responded to then
- sokoloff 6y agoShowing a use case where a digital asset is used as currency seems perfectly responsive to your comment that currency treatment doesn’t make sense for digital assets.
- vmception 6y agoI said for most digital assets. That wasn’t an accident. Utility tokens, security tokens, NFTs, wouldn’t make sense to be treated as currency, since I’m around people that require me to specify. And then you have an example that didn’t show how proper accepted legal designation as a currency, in the future, would lead to worse tax treatment, which is the supposition we were talking about. Let me know if you come up with something.
- refurb 6y agoIf you you make more than $200 USD because exchange rates changed, you are supposed to report that as capital gains. Of course, most don’t. https://www.irs.gov/publications/p525#en_US_2019_publink1000229538 https://www.irs.gov/publications/p525#en_US_2019_publink1000...
- sokoloff 6y agoI would argue in the case where I used the currency to buy something in that currency that I did not have a “gain on a currency transaction” of any amount.
- refurb 6y agoI would guess the IRS would disagree, since you're even supposed to pay taxes on bartering where no currency exchanges hands, just goods or services. So if you exchange $20 USD for foreign currency and then buy something a month later where it would have cost $25USD to get the same amount of currency, that's a capital gain.
- darksaints 6y agoI'm not aware of any worse tax consequences, but I guess it is possible considering the potential for those sweet long term capital gains rates. The problem I have with treating cryptocurrencies as property instead of currency is that it creates a massive accounting burden, effectively killing its potential use as a transactional currency. Can you imagine what it would be like if you had to report all of your bank statements, credit card transactions, and cash transactions to the IRS and have it all reconciled?
- prepend 6y agoYou have to record all forex investing gains and incomes. So if you have an account with euros and are exchanging them to dollars throughout the year to buy things, you must report gains and losses as well. I think the issue is that for tax purposes anytime something changes to dollars and gains or losses occur. Whether crypto is currency or an asset won’t affect this much. I think you need a new tax rule altogether that let people “settle up” at the end the tax period or something.
- DarthGhandi 6y ago> You have to record all forex investing gains and incomes. I'm not sure about the US but this is definitely not the case in the rest of the developed world. You are saying that every American citizen when they travel overseas, exchanging money and purchasing items on their card have to report that to the IRS? Get the feeling this only applies to professional traders not people on holiday.
- gamblor956 6y agoI'm not sure about the US but this is definitely not the case in the rest of the developed world. It actually is in the EU, and most of Asia. You are saying that every American citizen when they travel overseas, exchanging money and purchasing items on their card have to report that to the IRS? That is not forex investing. For most American citizens, the only taxable forex transaction would be when they convert the foreign currency back to USD, because that is the point at which the change in exchange rates may have created conversion-related gain or loss. (I.e., very simplified example: you paid $100 USD for $100 AUD on arriving in Sydney Australia, and paid $100 AUD for $110 USD leaving Australia, resulting in forex gain because the AUD became worth more by the time you left.) However, if you are not a person who regularly trades currencies, generally you don't have to report forex gain unless it exceeds $200 for the year (in the US; the threshold differs for each country).