3 ms·
This makes me wonder about the dynamics of copyright. As far as I understand it, copyright only really matters if you first create/obtain an infringing work, an
by derefr 6y ago
This makes me wonder about the dynamics of copyright. As far as I understand it, copyright only really matters if you first create/obtain an infringing work, and then introduce said infringing work into the market somehow (by distributing it, selling it, broadcasting it, etc.)
Copyright doesn’t seem to have much to say about infringing works created in private for private use, that never interact with the market. They’re infringing in theory, but in practice no copyright-holder has ever(?) gone after such infringement, because it’s just impractical to find out about it.
Now imagine an ML model that, when fed audio, emits perfect tabulature corresponding to said audio—without actually being overfit enough to contain an embedding of any real tabs; and where all the training data to the model was public-domain.
If an end-user of such a model applied it to a song, and what the model ended up synthesizing out was a copyrighted tab, then the end-user—and not the creator of the model—would be the one responsible for infringing upon the work, right? But, since that particular tab doesn’t exist anywhere except on their computer, then—if they just used it for practice, rather than publishing it—it’d be a private creation for private use, “invisible” to the copyright system.
It seems to me that, as long as the ML model didn’t actively advertise its ability to infringe on the copyrights of these particular tabs; or guide users into doing so; then it’d be safe to sell the model (or software that embeds it), right? Even safe to sell it as fit-for-purpose for being an aid in learning/practicing music.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoTechnically even making a copy of a CD for your own use counts as copyright infringement. When cars had CD players people would often make CDRs of their favourite CDs, and now people rip CDs to files. In theory all of this is illegal - because you don't buy the music with a CD, you buy a license to listen to the music from that particular run of the CD. Automated transcription - already a solved problem for solo piano and guitar, and partially solved for more complex source separation applications - would follow the same rules. So - technically an infringement, but you wouldn't be sued for private use. Sooner or later this will turn into an actual court case. Until then, the law on automated transcription is ambiguous. IANAL but I would guess it depend on whether a transcription product is sold as a "music ripper" for other people's work, or as a study aid for your own playing. And of course CD/stream ripper software has never been illegal. There have been various short-lived DRM efforts, but none of them seem to stick for long. Now it's fairly easy to rip Spotify playback, but no one seems to mind. But if you started running your own Spotify competitor they might - even on a small scale.
- user5994461 6y agoYou're very very wrong. Don't believe blindly everything that the music companies want you to believe. You don't buy the right to listen to a CD, you buy a copy of the CD and the music for use as you wish. Many European countries have an explicit right to private copy, you can copy/transform/archive anything you have for personal use. There is a tax on storage media that goes to the labels. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_copying_levy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_copying_levy I believe the US has something similar (you can do whatever you want with the copy that you own) but an American would be better place to comment on that. What you generally don't have (across jurisdictions) is the right to make copies and distribute them. CD rippers have never been illegal. They are illegal in a few places if they circumvent copy protection mechanisms and even there it depends on the details. You can have a look at the legal FAQ of VLC media player that debunks some of the myths. https://www.videolan.org/legal.html https://www.videolan.org/legal.html
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jameshart 6y agoSo on the surface, it seems like that would be fine, right? There's a piece of software called 'Capo', for example, that assists with the process of transcription, albeit not generating tab directly, but which analyzes a piece of music and helps you pick out and transcribe notes as tab - and for personal use, of course there's no problem doing so. It should be okay if it went further and attempted to autogenerate tabs. It does chords already, for example. And writing the tab out, for your own purposes, from a recording you have bought, is not infringing copyright on the original any more than listening to a copyrighted recording you have bought through speakers in your own home is infringing - I mean, it's possible that it could be considered 'format shifting' a work, like copying a vinyl onto a tape, but really it's more akin to just taking really detailed notes as you listen... And having a software tool that helps you do it seems like a reasonable thing to use, so how could it be infringing? In a way, if some ML software existed that could generate accurate tab from an audio file, then that software, plus a guitar, is just a really low-fidelity digital-to-analog converter pipeline for turning the original recording into audio. Just the same as an AAC codec + pair of headphones. The codec turns the original compressed data into a series of numbers representing audio samples, which a speaker turns into sounds; the Tab-transcribing ML turns the original data into a series of numbers representing which strings and frets to play, which a guitar player turns into sounds. So on that basis, it seems hard to argue that the existence of such an ML model is a copyright circumvention device, any more than you could argue that a speaker is a copyright infringement device. But... What if the way you trained the ML model in the first place, for example, was by feeding it copyrighted guitar tabs of copyrighted recordings? In particular, what if it was only for a very limited repertoire - say you just trained it on Hendrix recordings, and official licensed Hendrix tabs? Then, if you hand it something other than a Jimi Hendrix guitar performance, it might not be very good (although I bet the results would be interesting!) - but if you hand it any original Hendrix recording, the same recording of Little Wing that was used in training it, for example - then there's a really good chance it would just reproduce the official tab of Little Wing. The legal question might be, does the ML model embody the knowledge of how to produce a good tab from a recording, or just contain the memory of, and ability to reproduce, the copyrighted work? And when it comes to something like music, that gets very close to asking the question of, when it comes to a musical performer producing a song that sounds similar to a copyrighted work they were influenced by: Do they embody the knowledge of how to write a song that sounds like that or are they just reproducing their memory of the previous copyrighted work? Which gets to the 'originality' test in copyright law. And applying that in the case of an AI piece of software sounds... challenging. But on the other hand, it's pretty clear, for example, that when you hand an audio file to the AAC codec and it produces audio from it, that you can't argue that the codec is just reproducing the memory of the right sounds to make, prompted by the audio file - but on the other hand, it's not like the codec is bringing nothing to the table in terms of figuring out how to turn the 1s and 0s on disk into sounds.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]