5 ms·
This style of writing is responsible for 41% of the rage on the internet and I hate it. It's as if people forgot how to argue a valid point without becoming a t
by stjohnswarts 6y ago
This style of writing is responsible for 41% of the rage on the internet and I hate it. It's as if people forgot how to argue a valid point without becoming a troll. If this is the future of communication standards please someone just sneak up on me and insert an ice pick in my brain stem.
- 0-O-0 6y agoWhat was wrong with it, assuming it's factually correct?
- Causality1 6y agoSeconding this question. If it'd been me writing the article, and all the claims are true, it would've been a profanity-laced screed condemning the entire project as a pack of incompetent morons. It wouldn't charge so we turned off thermal regulation Jesus effing Christ.
- asou 6y agoMove fast and break things ! I recall once a co worker said they'd never use Android again since it froze when trying to call 911. Gives Apple more ammo in their fight against Epic, users expect their phones to work , which Apple can't guarantee if anyone can run whatever binary they find.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- choward 6y agoThe thing that about me the most is how much it's pushing fear without any evidence of something bad actually happening. Has there been a single pinephone that has caught on fire?
- linmob 6y agoI am not aware of any case of fire. So unless it caused such a bad fire, that everybody involved died, I think I would know about it having followed the PinePhone very closely, especially since June for my blog. That said, as the fix seems to be rather trivial, distributions should just check and ship a new kernel if necessary.
- harpiaharpyja 6y agoI don't get this criticism. Doesn't it make sense to raise the alarm before the fire happens?
- megous 6y agoYes, there were cases of Pinephone burning people's fingers, due to modem being used as a heatsink, and distros not doing any testing about thermal regulation working. You can easily get the modem to heat up to 70-80 deg C in that case. With regulation on, it would not get over 60, which while not pleasant is not at least hurtful.
- Ericson2314 6y agoThere evidentially is hardware logic in the battery itself so it's not factually correct. You might damange other pinephone components but the batter shouldn't catch fire. I wouldn't trust something as overly-complex as Linux to prevent fires anyways.
- megous 6y agoOk, so go to the Pinephone battery spec (everything is publicly available) and point me to where it says the in-battery protection circuit protects the under/overtemperature condition. In fact it's just the common protection circuit that just cares about over/under voltage and over-current conditions (mostly just a short, because the cuttoff current limit is 6-8A and battery's max recommended sustained current is 1.4A). So you can overload the battery 3-4x for however long you want, and that circuit will do nothing. https://megous.com/dl/tmp/d7402d89fca1a418.png https://megous.com/dl/tmp/d7402d89fca1a418.png
- jeffnappi 6y agoOn the surface I think you're right - but the author appears to be a contributor in the PinePhone community or is at least involved enough to be patching the kernel and testing out various features of PinePhone. That makes me think the author is genuinely concerned about the safety risks, however I do think the alarming communication tone is probably a little over the top :)
- megous 6y agoThe article is aimed at distro users to take action and start prodding the distro maintainers about how they make sure safety basics work on their phone. Style is tailored to that.