4 ms·
> Math, as we know it, is invented. But if it is invented then could we not have avoided inventing some of the more gnarly bits? If math is invented then, say,
by roenxi 6y ago
> Math, as we know it, is invented.
But if it is invented then could we not have avoided inventing some of the more gnarly bits? If math is invented then, say, irrational numbers were a terrible mistake.
The building blocks of math are entirely abstract, but once we define a circle in any half-satisfying way then all of the results in algebra, calculus and geometry are largely set in stone. After the invention of the circle in pre-written-history, most of the math that followed was discovery of the implications.
- thenoblesunfish 6y agoThe fun part is that what we invented is a set of rules that governs what else we may or may not invent! That is, once you agree on what logic is and what some axioms are, you can show that certain statements can't be added as axioms. Similarly, once you've decide on your axioms, and your set of logical tools, you will find some things (like irrational numbers), that you wouldn't have introduced directly. It's pretty cool!
- Tainnor 6y agoI mean, irrational numbers are maybe "ugly" from a certain perspective, but they are the price we pay for other things that make our life easier. Rational numbers are arguably nice and easy. But if all we have are rational numbers, 2 doesn't have a square root. More in general, our number line has holes, and one of the most fundamental properties of analysis - that every non-empty bounded set has a least upper bound - goes away. We could do away with that (and arguably, irrational numbers don't really exist "in the outside world") but it would make all the calculations so much more complicated.
- threatofrain 6y agoIrrationality is behavior which emerges from rational machinery. It is unavoidable.