4 ms·
I honestly hadn’t considered that before: cancel culture is an overreaction to an under reaction. I guess that’s just kind of what we do when we wield our prot
by Waterluvian 6y ago
I honestly hadn’t considered that before: cancel culture is an overreaction to an under reaction.
I guess that’s just kind of what we do when we wield our protest powers. I wonder if a sensible measured reaction would be met more openly (although maybe not even possible to do).
- marcinzm 6y agoAs I see it, measured reactions against power structures get squashed. Maybe you get a token appeasement that actually changes nothing. It's just too easy for those in power to make it go away so they logically go that route. Going overboard is the only way to force a reaction other than suppression (not guaranteed of course, you might just get massive suppression instead).
- colejohnson66 6y agoA good example of this is unionization. If a decent chunk of employees are upset about things, but you don’t do anything to alleviate it, they’re more likely to want to unionize so they can force the hand of their employer.
- Waterluvian 6y agoIntuitively I think you’re right. But I also think the side effect of overreaction is that those who disagree can very easily point at it to dismiss the cause’s legitimacy. “Can’t take them seriously at all. They want to cancel everyone and defund everything.”
- marcinzm 6y agoTrue but you generally get to this point where all other lesser options have failed. People are lazy and won't put the effort into mob justice if they see an easier approach. There have been decades of previous issues that simply were swept under the rug. I also don't think public opinion matters when it comes to mob justice. It's background noise. The conversation is between the mob and those in power. If the mob frightens them enough then changes will be made. What those outside the mob think is irrelevant unless they care enough to form their own mob.
- Waterluvian 6y agoI hear you. I wonder though if the amount that the mob frightens the power is affected by public opinion. Especially when it involves politicians.
- marcinzm 6y agoI think some politicians will care but it depends on the specifics of their voter bases. The mob and anti-mob groups tend to split across political lines so for many politicians one or the other are already lost causes. So it's a question of how your expected voter base thinks about the issue and that's likely to be a lot more skewed than the overall population. So even if 50% of the population is anti-mob, if 90% of your political party local voters are pro-mob then you have a reason to listen.
- krapp 6y agoIt's less that people are mob or anti-mob so much as pro their mob and anti the other mob. Don't forget that cancel culture is not an entirely left-wing phenomenon. Plenty of the same people who rail against SJWs and leftists cancelling people would have no problems with cancelling Bill Maher, the Dixie Chicks or Colin Kaepernick.
- ghaff 6y agoAnd it's largely random. Someone's ill-considered tweet or even post on an internal company email list or political donations or etc. ends up going viral, they get fired, and the whatever will be at the top of Google searches for possibly the rest of their life.
- 75dvtwin 6y agoI would think of the economic persecution of individuals as powerful weapon. just like with any weapon: - some will call it 'great equalizer'. Meaning that a victim no matter how small and physically weak, can still fight off a number of aggressors - some will call it a tool of death making, that belongs to the hands of military (in the case of cancel culture, it would be equivalent to saying that this tool belongs government ) Point is, just like usage of any weapon, the morality and legality of economic persecution depends on: - what / who is it used for - amount of collateral damage - who used it - were there other means, was it legal - the manipulative power of the legal team defending the use One thing we can sure of, any new weapon gets adapted by all sides of a conflict. The case of misuse of this weapon, in my view, was against Brendan Eich [1] [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/tonybradley/2014/04/05/backlash-against-brendan-eich-crossed-a-line/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/tonybradley/2014/04/05/backlash...
- ghaff 6y agoYou also had the bidirectional mess at PyCon a number of years back. One problem is that what is going to completely blow up is at least somewhat unpredictable. And, especially if an individual is low level/status (unlike Eich), many companies are going to take the path of least resistance and "kill them all and let God sort them out" so to speak. Which of course given that "blow up" is pretty much defined by social media footprint means that they'll also have whatever happened probably dog them is search results for a long time.