3 ms·
I get that everyone’s cheering for FB lose a lucrative market but this seems really stupid on the part of EU regulators. This is just the EU taking a jab at the
by Spivak 6y ago
I get that everyone’s cheering for FB lose a lucrative market but this seems really stupid on the part of EU regulators. This is just the EU taking a jab at the US government via Facebook than anything to do with Facebook itself.
If they actually go forward with this the “it doesn’t matter where the servers are” parts of the GPDR go out the window because, apparently, the EU can’t be sure that foreign governments (i.e. the US) won’t undermine data protection laws.
Which of course is literally true but if that’s your threat model then surely you can’t do business with any foreign based company since the US could just force FB to give them access to the EU data centers.
- loopback_device 6y ago> since the US could just force FB to give them access to the EU data centers. Which would then violate the EU laws, right?
- g_p 6y agoThis is indeed precisely what the US CLOUD Act does, which is the reason why this situation has arisen in the first place, since it does violate GDPR for a company to transfer data to a US entity like this.
- g_p 6y agoActually right now, since the Schrems II ruling, it doesn't matter where the servers are. The ruling identified that legislation in the US (Cloud Act) is incompatible with the principles that would allow data to be transferred absent the "privacy shield" agreement (standard contractual clauses, or binding corporate rules being the 2 main ones). Since the Cloud Act grants access to data hosted overseas, the problem with complying with GDPR is actually now the US legal entity having access or control of the data. Most commentary has focused on the location of the data as key, but in light of the Cloud Act and FISA 702, it comes down to whether or not the data is subject to such laws. On a similar note, many commenters are suggesting if the data is encrypted, that makes it OK. This is true only in limited circumstances (like S3, where you decrypt the data without the US entity seeing the keys). It isn't true where the data is processed by the US entity (absent homomorphic encryption). A lot of misunderstanding around the ruling, but indeed this is the EU saying to the US government, "we are not satisfied your jurisdiction offers protections legally compliant to let your services into our market."