4 ms·
You've just explained that the costs will be lower, not that the quality will be lower. It's possible costs will be lower due to better efficiency and hiring in
by chrisseaton 6y ago
You've just explained that the costs will be lower, not that the quality will be lower. It's possible costs will be lower due to better efficiency and hiring in different markets, not due to worse pilots.
Hiring me in the UK is cheaper than hiring someone else in Silicon Valley. I don't think that necessarily means I'm any worse a programmer, does it?
- masklinn 6y ago> You've just explained that the costs will be lower, not that the quality will be lower. I've explained that there are no incentives for the quality being the same, only for costs to be lower. Which has essentially always resulted in quality dropping. Including in Boeing's own recent history. > It's possible costs will be lower due to better efficiency and hiring in different markets, not due to worse pilots. It's also possible that you start shooting solid gold out your ass. > Hiring me in the UK is cheaper than hiring someone else in Silicon Valley. I don't think that necessarily means I'm any worse a programmer, does it? If the goal is solely to hire a cheaper developer, it's not you they'll be going to.
- mattr47 6y agoHigher cost does not equal higher quality.
- bronson 6y agoObviously. The OP said you need to look to the incentives to see what’s actually happening.
- chrisseaton 6y agoDo you think there's never any inefficiency in a system? It's possible they could lower cost but keep the same quality. There's an incentive to do that.
- bronson 6y agoIf you’re saying that Boeing currently incentivizes quality over cost, what evidence are you basing that on? There are lots of news articles on the development of the 787 and 737MAX showing Boeing only too willing to compromise on quality. If you’re just speculating that it’s technically still possible, then how is that valuable discussion? As OP said, it’s also technically possible to crap gold. So what?
- valuearb 6y agoAre you saying that Boeing’s huge 737 Max mistakes and run our laden news articles mean that every management decision at Boeing reduces quality? Perhaps the pilots union wanted $400k a year for each pilot, but their market value was only $200K a year?
- sokoloff 6y agoIt’s not that you’re a worse programmer but rather that if I hire a contracting firm that employs you and a dozen programmers worse than you, that you’re the one on the initial sales and scoping calls, then if I’ve thought to ask, you’re assigned to my project for a few weeks until you are pulled off (to the next sales engagement requiring someone actually competent) and a less competent programmer from the bench is free to take your seat. Then, when the project starts falling behind, another is added on T&M basis because some scope changed somewhere no doubt... The firm has every incentive to do this (including hiring cheap programmers who would have difficulty remaining employed directly on their abilities) and I’ve seen this happen more than rarely. There are good and terrible programmers everywhere in the world, yet I can’t ever recall the “new programmer on your account” being excellent; I don’t think that’s by chance. The “outsourcing” of critical functions concerns me way more than the “off-shoring” does.