2 ms·
Two out of the three words of the title contain buzz words (CHECK!) Ok but seriously I don't see the "bubble" here. If this is a "bubble" what are the implicat
by mbesto 16y ago
Two out of the three words of the title contain buzz words (CHECK!)
Ok but seriously I don't see the "bubble" here. If this is a "bubble" what are the implications of it popping? The value is set by the people who exchange it and not by a governing authority or even, groups of people. As I understand it, that means the value can never be manipulated. Also, don't bubbles imply that there is some sort of governing body that either decreases or increases risk of such an asset? For example in the housing and tech bubble, this would largely be the SEC (among many others). People were wildly spending and loaning money because risk was largely reduced -- a combination of guaranteed government bailouts and "everyone else is doing it!". How is any risk reduced using Bitcoin? If anything isn't Bitcoin a way to prevent bubbles? I see it as real value assessment set democratically by people using the currency.
I don't see Bitcoin itself as "irrational exuberance" at all, in fact quite the opposite. It's attempting to solve a real world problem. Indeed the referring article might suggest that the analysts covering Bitcoin are acting irrationally by making claims like "government take heed, there's a new currency in town". But just as the words "Bitcoin" and "Bubble" were used to grab attention to this article, the analysts covering Bitcoin also (here- Jerry Brito) will make irrational and largely speculative claims to bring viewership.
- stonemetal 16y agoThere were bubbles long before government got involved in the market, in fact such bubbles are why the government is involved in the market now. The primary problem with bitcoins as it stands now is that there is no oversight so any sort of price manipulation possible is legal.
- mbesto 16y agoRe: Bubbles - Such as? Let me be more specific. If I shall quote wikipedia - "It could also be described as a trade in products or assets with inflated values" Doesn't Bitcoin set to eliminate inflated values? With no central authority controlling the amount of currency available or loaned at certain rates then valuation becomes absolute, no? Re: Manipulation - I'm not sure I understand how the value of the currency can be manipulated. If the value is directly set by the end user then it's impossible to manipulate.
- stonemetal 16y agoIf the value is directly set by the end user then it's impossible to manipulate. Only if it is impossible to manipulate the end user. Aka there is nothing in the system to prevent fraud or any other pump and dump scheme you can come up with. So no, with no fraud controls in place Bitcoin does nothing to eliminate inflated values, and really can't unless they have come up with a technological solution to lying. An example of a bubble before the SEC was created, and in fact lead to its creation. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wall_Street_Crash_of_1929 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wall_Street_Crash_of_1929 The rising share prices encouraged more people to invest; people hoped the share prices would rise further. Speculation thus fueled further rises and created an economic bubble.
- kd0amg 16y agoI don't see Bitcoin itself as "irrational exuberance" at all, in fact quite the opposite. It's attempting to solve a real world problem. A lot of people I've heard promoting Bitcoin (n.b. these are not analysts) gloss over or outright ignore the more pressing real world problem of being able to spend it on the things you want/need. The solution I hear most often is "convert it to USD." It looks like we're left with two possible outcomes. Either adoption grows large enough soon enough that converting to USD (or another currency) is no longer a necessary step in using BTC for most transaction, or people get bored/tired of waiting for that time to come and decide to cash out. The latter is the proposed bubble pop scenario, where people decide that they would much rather have some currency other than BTC, and are progressively willing to trade their BTC for less and less other currency. As for its implications, I'm not too worried. I'd expect the worst thing that could come out of it would be increased difficulty in getting similar projects to succeed in the future.