5 ms·
> My job is to fill the headcount that I've got, so as long as it fits within budget, whatever. Exactly, but the budget isn't infinite. Assuming equal talent,
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> My job is to fill the headcount that I've got, so as long as it fits within budget, whatever.
Exactly, but the budget isn't infinite.
Assuming equal talent, I'd much rather hire 5 people at market rate rather than 4 people at 25% over market rate. The net cost is roughly the same, but we can get much more accomplished with 1 more person on the team. Even better, on-call demands are spread out over more people and vacations are easier to schedule.
In my experience, compensation requests are only loosely coupled to a person's abilities. Usually, the person's prior salary history is the driving factor, even when they don't reveal it (I don't ask). If you have a large enough candidate pool, it can often make sense to let the most aggressive negotiators go to the FAANG companies rather than jumping through hoops to overpay them relative to the rest of the team. The most aggressive salary seekers usually end up leaving for FAANG anyway, because they want the resume prestige as leverage in future salary negotiations.
Finally, handing out above market salaries isn’t without consequence for managers. When C-level execs look at compensation across the company and see a handful of managers with significantly higher compensation, they’re going to have higher expectations for that team. If a manager is constantly paying above-market rates but producing average or below average work, it’s going to draw attention. If I’m going out on a limb to give people above market compensation, the expectations are that much higher. I’m also going to be that much quicker to let highly compensated people go if they can’t live up to their compensation requests.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- etothepii 6y agoThe issue is that the non-salary costs routinely make up an additional 50-100% of a head count and many of these are fixed. Thus to replace a team of 4 with a team of 5, you might need to negotiate their salary component down 30% not 20%. Thus the manager hiring the team of 4 appears to be paying 42% more.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI'd much rather hire 4 above average people than 5 average people. Having more people adds its own cost and there is a Pareto law in people's contributions. Edit: Basically, IMHO, in terms of assembling the best team to deliver the best results it's better to keep things as small as possible. But in terms of internal company politics it's better to grow the team as much as possible.
- JoshTriplett 6y ago> I'd much rather hire 4 above average people than 5 average people. That's assuming that negotiation skill is closely correlated with the skill you're actually hiring for, rather than being correlated with having read an article like this, or some other somewhat orthogonal knowledge.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThe level of salary you pay is correlated to what type of people you attract and what type of people you keep. If you want better than average people you have to be prepared to offer better that average compensation. That's what it boils down to. The actual negotiation only moves things at the margin and the initial offer already tells if the company pays well or not. The company's reputation also already told that to candidates. Of course it's indeed important for the candidate to get the best deal because, as mentioned in another comment, that has a knock-on effect over time.
- JoshTriplett 6y agoAbsolutely agreed on all counts. To the extent this is a factor of the company's intended salary range rather than just the candidates negotiation skill, I'd agree that paying more for better folks is likely to pay off disproportionately in many cases.
- yowlingcat 6y ago> That's assuming that negotiation skill is closely correlated with the skill you're actually hiring for People overestimate negotiation as a "skill." It's not. It's leverage, it's BATNA. Negotiation is having more than one offer and using that to explore the difference between the initial offer space and the maximum offer space between firms based on a basket of offers. The skill is in getting an offer from more than one company in the first place. And I would wager that if you're hiring professionals, having that kind of ownership and thoroughness is often exactly what you want to hire for, even more than the direct experience.
- etothepii 6y ago
- tasuki 6y ago> but we can get much more accomplished with 1 more person on the team Are you sure of that? Two people can usually accomplish much more than one person, but how much more do you achieve with 5 people rather than 4? My guess would be that adding the fifth person to a team increases productivity between 5-15%.
- williamdclt 6y agoIt's never that simple, really. Is the extra person just "an extra pair of hand" or are they filling a spot that nobody is currently successful at? I'm in a 4 person team currently, give me an additional project manager and productivity will soar as devs can focus on technical aspects, rather than being inefficient at PMing for a mediocre output (at least that's my expectation, you never know in advance I suppose)
- tasuki 6y agoAgreed, if people are in different roles, an extra pair of hands can be fully productive. As soon as the fifth person is eg working on the same codebase of the previous four, there arises necessary overhead and stepping on each others' toes.
- ISL 6y agoIt would depend upon the work. If the work is embarrassingly parallel, then 25% more. (5/4 = 1.25, of course) If there is too much work for four people to function effectively, perhaps more than 25%. If the work requires a lot of inter-process communication, perhaps less than 25%.
- tasuki 6y agoYou're right, thank you.
- yowlingcat 6y agoFor what it's worth, this is what Amazon's compensation philosophy is with how RSUs are backloaded. It's fine if you can't actually translate the extra talent you get from the more expensive FAANG level engineers into business value as long as you're upfront about it. But for some tech companies, having 4 engineers at that level is way more useful than 5 engineers 25% less expensive. Your average per IC intellectual horsepower is higher. You often get to solve problems a different way -- to use your example, maybe the on-call burden ends up being lower even being a smaller team because those 4 engineers will find a way to make it so.
- quicklime 6y agoYeah that’s true. So I should clarify that I do care about my department’s budget, but the sum of money we’re talking about here is like $5-10k, or about 2.5-5% of someone’s loaded cost. I’d much rather secure a good candidate than squabble over that. If they’re asking for an extra $50k, then it’s a different scenario. I hear people justify not negotiating by saying things like “I’m worried what they’ll think of me” or “I don’t want to create trouble”. This is what people think I care about, but don’t. And as others have said, absolutely this is different for small companies where they’ll feel it more personally.
- scarface74 6y agoThe don’t overpay because they are going to a FAANG anyway is a very good point. I am way to old to care about prestige (ie. the 74), but my company of 50 people in GA could never have offered me the $75K difference between what they were paying me pre-Covid pay cut and what BigTech offered me for my current remote role. Why try?