2 ms·
> Okay, so how much time does it take to make a steel sword with modern techniques and machines to do all the work mentioned? A random Cold Steel longsword was
by samatman 6y ago
> Okay, so how much time does it take to make a steel sword with modern techniques and machines to do all the work mentioned?
A random Cold Steel longsword was about five hundred bucks, after a quick search.
Figuring 100% markup and the rest labor averaging $15/hr, about 17 hours of labor.
That's an extremely lazy calculation, but it has to be in the right ballpark.
- CydeWeys 6y agoIt's also worth pointing out that swords haven't remotely benefited from large economies of scale in the same way that other modern manufactured goods have simply because swords are a niche good in the modern day and aren't manufactured in the millions annually like other things are. If you want to compare like-for-like, look at goods that are as important in the modern day as swords were in medieval times. One similar enough modern example (because it's also worked metal) would be silverware; you can easily get stainless forks, knives, and spoons in bulk for less than a buck nowadays. Metal silverware in the medieval era was so expensive and thus such a luxury good that only the elites had it. Common people ate with their hands or roughly whittled wooden cutlery. There's also the problem that stainless steel wasn't invented yet, and other metal substitutes for it in cutlery applications are either much more expensive (silver/gold), or rust.
- samatman 6y agoDefinitely, contemporary swords are boutique luxury items. A good machete is about 30 bucks, and a sword is fancier, but not much: $60 is a decent guess at the price of a quality sword, if they were an important sidearm that most people needed to have.
- CydeWeys 6y agoYeah, I was thinking of machetes too. There are of course trash novelty swords at a similar price range, but those aren't so great at the actual job of cutting things. Machetes are. Also, $30 gets you a good machete (as distinct from fancy/hand-made). $5 gets you a cheap Harbor Freight machete that nevertheless does seem like it does the job. If we manufactured swords in the same volume we do chef's knifes, machetes, hammers, screwdrivers, prybars, etc., they'd be super cheap.
- kbenson 6y agoI meant that to be a but more rhetorical, but it does express my point. In the past it was far more expensive, and other than the assumption of how much of the cost is the final stage labor and how much is materials cost (and to some degree labor cost, which also has changed over time), the same calculations can be used roughly to approximate relative cost of items in other time periods. In the past, a vastly higher proportion of the cost would have been base materials, but also they might take some of that in-house, if there aren't industries to support manufacture of materials to a form better suited to the final stage of manufacture. What if the cost of the steel going into a modern sword was something like $10k-$20k because it was so costly to harvest and process because of labor? That then makes you wonder why steel is so expensive, and now you're using economics as a window to peer into into how ancient economies worked. :)