14 ms·
I said: > (I'm not against CUA bindings by default - merely pointing out a misconception you have). And you respond with: > I don't really buy the argument I
by BeetleB 6y ago
I said:
> (I'm not against CUA bindings by default - merely pointing out a misconception you have).
And you respond with:
> I don't really buy the argument I'm afraid.
And then you write a whole comment about how CUA is better.
Which argument did I make that you don't buy? Why is this a reply to my comment?
> I do think it's well worth a look at present-day alternatives and to make sure it doesn't fall behind.
In all my jobs that used IDEs (including JetBrains's excellent stuff), I used both the IDE and Emacs - the latter for text editing, etc. The former for all the goodies it brings (navigation, etc). There's no law saying it has to be one or the other. IDEs becoming very popular in no way threatens Emacs.
> Because I think it actually has fallen behind, and it needs to get its act together to retain its relevance.
I could really easily write a whole article on all the features Emacs has that many more popular editors don't have, and then end the article with "Those other editors are falling behind."
We have to clearly delineate what "falling behind" means, and whether it is relevant. VS Code gaining in popularity doesn't necessarily impact Emacs. In my career I've met an order of magnitude more Vim users, and Emacs is not the worse because of it. Emacs's capabilities have grown much faster than Vim's has, and Emacs has a lot more users than it used to. Furthermore, most Vim users I've encountered at work are not fairly advanced users: They just need something to edit files with. Having them switch to Emacs will neither help them nor the Emacs community.
I don't mind some of the proposed changes (nicer defaults, revamping the tutorial, etc). But I really don't want a mindless goal of increasing user counts. More users will not make Emacs gain more capabilities. Passionate users will.