3 ms·
Bijections aren't necessarily isomorphisms. A bijection is just a one-to-one correspondence between two sets; an isomorphism also preserves functional and relat
by btilly 16y ago
Bijections aren't necessarily isomorphisms. A bijection is just a one-to-one correspondence between two sets; an isomorphism also preserves functional and relational structure on those sets.
That is an important distinction, but it tends to be pretty easy for most people.
Another important distinction, which I personally found much harder, is the distinction between an isomorphism and a natural isomorphism. Which is that a natural isomorphism is an isomorphism that is defined by the functional and relational structure on those sets.
I had so completely ingrained the idea that "isomorphic means the same" that it was hard for me to understand that some pairs of things were more "the same" than others. What part of "same" didn't my teachers understand?
The classic example involves vector spaces. The set of linear functions from a finite dimensional vector space over the reals to the reals is a vector space. It turns out to be isomorphic to the original vector space, but not naturally isomorphic. This second vector space is called the dual. The reason why is that the dual of the dual is naturally isomorphic to the original vector space. The natural isomorphism is defined like this. If v is a vector in the original space, and f is a linear function, then map v to the function v' defined by v'(f) = f(v).
As difficult as it was for me to understand this, it does turn out to be important. For instance the distinction between a vector space and its dual is closely related to the distinction between covariant and contravariant.