4 ms·
Browsers being able to download ftp protocol links is a really useful function. Security it an odd reason to me to remove this feature as anonymous ftp doesn’t
by prepend 6y ago
Browsers being able to download ftp protocol links is a really useful function.
Security it an odd reason to me to remove this feature as anonymous ftp doesn’t really have much of an issue.
- pixl97 6y agoEh, FTP protocol is a mess, especially in a NAT based world.
- jsilence 6y agoWould like to understand what you mean. Care to elaborate
- magicalhippo 6y agoIt requires a separate port for transferring data. And unless the FTP server supports passive transfers (and they're still out there to this day) that connection is in the opposite direction.
- jsilence 6y agoThanks!
- Minor49er 6y agoI agree about its usefulness. Personally, when I'm using FTP, I seek out a native client anyways. As long as the browser will open up the client when an FTP link is clicked, I think it would be fine. Let the HTTP browsers focus on HTTP. I mean, browsers don't tend to have built in functionality for things like email or phone calls.
- comex 6y agoEven if your connection doesn’t have credentials to steal, anyone who can observe your network traffic can snoop on what files you’re downloading, and a MitM attacker can serve you altered versions of those files. This is especially problematic given that one of the most common remaining use cases for anonymous-FTP-in-browser is downloading software, so there’s a good chance you’re about to execute those potentially-altered files as code. Of course, unencrypted HTTP has the exact same problems – but browsers are trying to deprecate that too, even if they can’t actually remove support anytime soon.
- prepend 6y agoI’m aware of this risk and don’t care. The files I FTP down are things I don’t care about. I don’t think there’s a “good chance” of someone altering the files I download. It’s certainly possible, although unlikely based on the number of times it’s happened to me (0) vs the times I’ve served or retrieved an ftp file (millions, perhaps billions).
- fomine3 6y agoIn the case you're downloading Tor Browser in some countries