3 ms·
> Emacs is in that disastrous stage of a product's life where the geezers destroy their own community by refusing to adapt to new expected behavior It doesn't
by BeetleB 6y ago
> Emacs is in that disastrous stage of a product's life where the geezers destroy their own community by refusing to adapt to new expected behavior
It doesn't look like your an Emacs user. As another commenter pointed out (as did the article indirectly), Emacs has more users than ever. It's definitely growing - not dwindling. As an Emacs user, the last decade has shown an immense growth in capabilities via MELPA packages. The number of sites with tips on improving Emacs flows has also gone up exponentially.
Not only is it not dying, it's thriving.
> They were standard when Ronald Reagan was president.
For a whole other definition of standard. A lot of the popular DOS applications from Reagan/Bush's time did not use these keybindings. Ctrl-Ins and Shift-Ins were the norm. Ctrl-C for quitting was the norm.
(I'm not against CUA bindings by default - merely pointing out a misconception you have).
> But for everyone else, Emacs is a small part of a much larger ecosystem (MacOS, Linux, Windows) with which it is increasingly incompatible and archaic.
Actually, Emacs is pretty good at interacting with the wider ecosystems. It can communicate and interact with other processes, etc. I can, for example, link to a message in MS Outlook and have it open up in my TODO list in Emacs.
- SeanLuke 6y ago> It doesn't look like your an Emacs user. I have been an avid Emacs user since, I think, 1988. > A lot of the popular DOS applications Bzzt. 35 years ago the standard was Windows and MacOS. Soon thereafter NeXTSTEP and nearly all X11 apps adapted the same.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoWhile Windows technically existed in '85, no one statistically was using it yet. Other's copied the CUA interface into the late 80s however.
- icedchai 6y agoWindows didn't start going anywhere until Windows 3.0 in 1990. Windows 95 was really where it went mainstream.
- mi_lk 6y ago> Emacs has more users than ever. It's definitely growing - not dwindling. Growing in terms of the number of users, dwindling in terms of the share among editors
- nobody9999 6y ago>Growing in terms of the number of users, dwindling in terms of the share among editors That's as may be. Just because something has a high market share doesn't mean it's the best product. Chrome is by far the most "popular" browser by market share, and that doesn't stop it from doing all kinds of stuff that benefits Google over users -- often to the detriment of those users.
- Jtsummers 6y agoMarket share shouldn't matter. The numbers that do matter: Are the number of contributors increasing, decreasing, or stable? Are the number of users increasing, decreasing, or stable? Is the rate of increase (if increasing) for either of these itself increasing, decreasing, or stable? As long as contributors and users are both increasing, you're probably ok. As long as the rates of increase are at least stable, you're ok. It's not like this is a life or death struggle, emacs will probably outlive us all.
- JdeBP 6y agoHistorical note: CUA didn't come along until 1987. In 1985, the Lisa had been out for two years, and CUA was that far into the future, as indeed were Windows 2.0 and OS/2 1.0. It's true that the claim that the Mac/Lisa key chords were the standard 35 years ago is quite wrong. But it's false to claim that there was another standard instead.
- rleigh 6y agoI don't really buy the argument I'm afraid. I've been an Emacs user for over 20 years. I like it, and find it productive. But it's stuck in a rut, in a very similar manner to Perl 5. If that isn't addressed, it will fade into the background. I'd argue that's already happened. None of my coworkers in any of the jobs I've worked in have used it, and that includes academia and various industries. It seems to be restricted to the uber-nerds who find out about it and go through the pain of learning how to drive it effectively. I used to use it for everything, from GNUS to org-mode, but my usage is declining. The keybindings need to be fixed. CUA has been the norm for what, 35 years at this point. C-y is paste. C-z minimises the window (WTF!) C-_ is undo. It's not just nonstandard and counterintutive, it's unnecessarily nonstandard and counterintuitive. They aren't more efficient, they aren't more effective. It's a barrier to adoption which doesn't need to be there. It has a certain familiarity for us long-time users, but that's about it. Every other application uses something based on CUA, so it's not like we couldn't switch over. While I certainly wouldn't want a "GNOME 3" type of makeover, where all the actual userbase are cast aside to be replaced by a hypothetical potential userbase which doesn't actually exist, I do think it's well worth a look at present-day alternatives and to make sure it doesn't fall behind. Because I think it actually has fallen behind, and it needs to get its act together to retain its relevance. Recently I got a personal JetBrains subscription and started using CLion. While I still miss many little small features, there are quite a number of big features which Emacs doesn't attempt to do, and so the small annoyances are worth it for those large benefits. Emacs needs to be able to do better than this to not only keep up, but to do better than its competitors.
- htns 6y agoThe CUA issue seems frivolous, since retention among those who don't even do the built-in tutorial on the splash page was never going to be high. It might help somewhat, but the bigger issue with emacs is the association with spacemacs (vi), lisp, and "configurability", which attracts some but perhaps leads many more to disregard emacs as Kool-Aid and never even try it. The reason to use emacs is that the text-editing is superior. magit, org-mode, email, and so on having an unified interface is great, but the text-editing (navigation, mark and region, macros, rectangles, and more) is what I miss acutely when using anything else, and it's also the reason why the rest of emacs exists.