3 ms·

I can't speak towards his attitude toward security flaws, but I think his reaction to not wanting Calibre updated is reasonable. Anytime a UI is updated, you'r

I can't speak towards his attitude toward security flaws, but I think his reaction to not wanting Calibre updated is reasonable. Anytime a UI is updated, you're going to completely modify the behavior or of the people that are using it. So any change someone else is making that isn't as closely tied with the product as he is, is probably going to be suboptimal. Not only from a user experience perspective, but also from his ability to answer questions on the forum as people are asking him questions about how to achieve certain things. This means that he'll HAVE to be closely tied with a redesign. Which is probably not where he wants to be spending a significant amount of his time. There's also the added complexity of legacy users that are just book people, that are quite used to the design as it is, so any migration over the new one, no matter how gradual, is probably going to make the product harder for them to use. I'm not saying I agree or disagree with him, but his reasoning is valid. This isn't a project where you just hand off to someone completely new and let them do what they want. That's how you end up with a broken product.

Mediterraneo10 6y ago
Goyal doesn’t have to be closely involved in the forum helping users. I question the importance of his doing so while the UI is what it is. It could be that while a small number of users are helped by his personal attention on the forum, a much larger number of users are left frustrated by the UI.
- pnutjam 6y ago
  I've never had any real issues with the UI. I run it locally, and sync it to a cloudserver where I run it headless. Both the local and web ui are fine IMHO. They allow me to get things done and the work.
- hombre_fatal 6y ago
  The UI isn't pretty and it can be clunky at times, but it's functional. UI is hard, and I guarantee a lot harder than you think it is just by how flippantly you've described the endeavor so far. Also, be wary of judging someone by how they choose to spend their free time. Notice how you haven't actually lifted a finger yourself, just judged others for how they lift theirs with zero skin in the game.
- itsovermyhead 6y ago
  He doesn't HAVE to be, but he is. Isn't that a good thing? > It could be that while a small number of users are helped by his personal attention on the forum, a much larger number of users are left frustrated by the UI. This is just speculation. Without data to back it up, I can say the reverse is true too. Since there isn't a large number of users that are posting about how terrible the UI is(on the Calibre forum), it's probably functional enough and people can navigate it.
  - Izkata 6y ago
    > it's probably functional enough Buttons look like buttons, not text. It's better than modern UIs. I fear that if he gives in, this and similar small details would change so it looks nice instead of being easy to use.
- cedilla 6y ago
  Does it matter what's more important though? He's the only one who gets to decide what he spends his time on.

Mediterraneo10 6y ago

Goyal doesn’t have to be closely involved in the forum helping users. I question the importance of his doing so while the UI is what it is. It could be that while a small number of users are helped by his personal attention on the forum, a much larger number of users are left frustrated by the UI.

pnutjam 6y ago
I've never had any real issues with the UI. I run it locally, and sync it to a cloudserver where I run it headless. Both the local and web ui are fine IMHO. They allow me to get things done and the work.
hombre_fatal 6y ago
The UI isn't pretty and it can be clunky at times, but it's functional. UI is hard, and I guarantee a lot harder than you think it is just by how flippantly you've described the endeavor so far. Also, be wary of judging someone by how they choose to spend their free time. Notice how you haven't actually lifted a finger yourself, just judged others for how they lift theirs with zero skin in the game.
itsovermyhead 6y ago
He doesn't HAVE to be, but he is. Isn't that a good thing? > It could be that while a small number of users are helped by his personal attention on the forum, a much larger number of users are left frustrated by the UI. This is just speculation. Without data to back it up, I can say the reverse is true too. Since there isn't a large number of users that are posting about how terrible the UI is(on the Calibre forum), it's probably functional enough and people can navigate it.
- Izkata 6y ago
  > it's probably functional enough Buttons look like buttons, not text. It's better than modern UIs. I fear that if he gives in, this and similar small details would change so it looks nice instead of being easy to use.
cedilla 6y ago
Does it matter what's more important though? He's the only one who gets to decide what he spends his time on.