3 ms·
Bijective functions are of interest to me for practical purposes in data binding, UIs and the like. Having a reversible function translating data from one form
by barrkel 16y ago
Bijective functions are of interest to me for practical purposes in data binding, UIs and the like. Having a reversible function translating data from one form to another makes creating bindings more declarative, as you don't have to prove that the getter and setter halves are equivalent (the usual alternative), if your function to begin with is bijective.
And for this practical purpose, I also don't care about preserving functional and relational structure in the mapped sets - isomorphism is not particularly relevant.
So what I'd like to know is why exactly you think this is "concerning". What bad ramifications are you afraid of?
- ionfish 16y agoWell, I'm afraid that people will believe you! For your purposes it might not matter whether all bijections are isomorphisms, but it does matter to other people (for practical as well as theoretical purposes). What worries me is that someone may come along, see a nicely-written article appearing to summarise the nature of some important classes of functions, take it at face value, and go away believing that all bijections are isomorphisms, only to have this belief trip them up at some later stage. Not everyone is going to hop on Wikipedia or open up a maths textbook to verify your assertions, after all.
- eru 16y agoIf you don't care about standard terminology, you might as well name your function red, green and blue, instead of re-using those complicated words like injective in a non-standard manner.
- barrkel 16y agoHang on, I'm not saying I don't care about standard terminology - I'm saying I care a lot more about the bijective property than the isomorphic property.
- swift 16y agoA bijective function (also called isomorphic) is a one-to-one mapping between the persons and the bikes (between the domain and codomain). That's the assertion made in the article - that a bijection and an isomorphism are the same thing. That's just not correct, and the distinction matters in general, even if you have not yet encountered a situation where it caused a problem. If you care only about the bijective property, why bring isomorphism into it?
- btilly 16y agoHang on, I'm not saying I don't care about standard terminology Actions speak louder than words. You have been corrected about your terminology by multiple people. Your response has been to not make the obvious correction, and to tell people that you don't care about what you are being corrected on. This is very strong evidence that you do not, in fact, care about standard terminology.
- ionfish 16y agoIn fairness, barrkel is not the author of the original article, he's just defending him. I initially made this mistake too--hence my "I'm afraid that people will believe you!" (my emphasis). Unfortunately it's too late to edit my post above to clarify.
- btilly 16y agoDo you have evidence that they are different people? Until you pointed it out, I hadn't noticed the fact that the user name being used here is different than the name that the blog was posted under and different yet again from the person who chose to post it here. But I could easily see person A posting to a blog, person B putting it here, person A noticing the traffic, and coming here to comment with a user name that didn't match. So it is not clear to me that the person responding here is not the person who wrote the article.
- ionfish 16y agoThe article was written by someone called Martin Matusiak, or at least that's what it says on his home page [1]. Apparently he lives in Utrecht. barrkel's blog [2] (linked off his HN profile), on the other hand, says his name is Barry Kelly, and he lives in London. They do, however, both work with Delphi. [1] http://www.matusiak.eu/numerodix/ http://www.matusiak.eu/numerodix/ [2] http://blog.barrkel.com/ http://blog.barrkel.com/
- barrkel 16y agoI think the prior probability of me (or any other random commenter who's been on this site for many years) being any posted article's author has got to pretty small, and that you ought to have a higher bar of evidence for believing such than the ability to easily imagine such a scenario, especially in some kind of sock-puppet case, which you seem to be implying. (Frankly, it's bizarre and a little insulting, because it implies I had a conflict of interest I didn't disclose.)