> With my end user hat on, I respectfully disagree. SIWA is tied to my Apple ID, and is my account. From a capability standpoint, I agree. From user perception

> With my end user hat on, I respectfully disagree. SIWA is tied to my Apple ID, and is my account. From a capability standpoint, I agree. From user perception and resulting corporate liability standpoints, there are problems there. > Apple has demonstrated it will unilaterally revoke my login on services that has nothing to do with it, thereby significantly reducing the value of SIWA and significantly increasing the risk of using it. Apple _only_ allows SiwA with organizations which have an Apple developer account, which has the terms and conditions for appropriate use of user PII. It is certainly valid to put users squarely in charge of who they share their PII to, but that requires a different user experience with appropriate informed consent. The SiwA experience is still about letting Apple share data with partner organizations.