3 ms·
I feel like recently the semantic web is gaining a bit of a resurgance with wikidata. But i think the general vision of individual mutually untrusted individua
by bawolff 6y ago
I feel like recently the semantic web is gaining a bit of a resurgance with wikidata.
But i think the general vision of individual mutually untrusted individuals participating in an interconnected knowledge graph is pretty dead.
* its hard to do quality/concistency control on that which makes the results less useful.
* RDF is rediculously complicated. Microformats/rdfa is a bit better, but still it essentially requires specialist knowledge to do this properly. This strongly discourages average joe from just adding annotations.
* unclear value proposition at the small scale.
* it is very difficult to scale complex queries on large semantic data sets. It can often be hard to predict how performance will change over time. Compare to traditional relational DBs which have very predictable scalability and lots of DBAs who know how to optimize. I think this is probably the biggest hurdle to large-scale adoption.
* * key example: the example queries at https://query.wikidata.org https://query.wikidata.org are pretty magical, but when you try your own, you can quickly run into timeouts, especially when nested deeply in a graph (e.g. find all species of plants matching some property)
- bloaf 6y agoMathematica seems to be betting on knowledge graphs https://www.wolfram.com/language/12/rdf-and-sparql https://www.wolfram.com/language/12/rdf-and-sparql and ctrl+f the RDF section here: https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2019/04/version-12-launches-today-big-jump-for-wolfram-language-and-mathematica https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2019/04/version-12-launc...