5 ms·
Very nuanced analysis! Fantastic. In the past, the effects of freedom of speech were bounded by the cost of communication. Very few people could afford a soapb
by echelon 6y ago
Very nuanced analysis! Fantastic.
In the past, the effects of freedom of speech were bounded by the cost of communication. Very few people could afford a soapbox with which to reach the world, so only certain messages were broadcast widely. Now everyone can send (and even amplify) messages quickly and easily.
Previously celebrities, politicians, the media, and advertisers had a wide channel. Now interest groups, state actors, echo chambers, and individuals with access to technology such as GPT-3 can do the same.
There's a lot of good, but also a lot of bad. We're now testing how humans respond to this deluge. It's fascinating (and somewhat worrying) to watch unfold.
My biggest fear is that state actors will inject information designed to polarize us, and that we'll respond exactly as they want.
- slg 6y ago>My biggest fear is that state actors will inject information designed to polarize us, and that we'll respond exactly as they want. Are you being facetious with this? This has been a long documented behavior of Russia. The future you fear is already here.
- xtian 6y agoLong-documented behavior of the US to other countries as well.
- FillardMillmore 6y agoMost modern states with the necessary capabilities spread disinformation to other countries for their own political gain or the political gain of their allies, Russia is far from the only one.
- slg 6y agoFair, but Russia is the most direct example of the specific fears mentioned in spreading disinformation with the goal of polarization as opposed to a different specific goal. When the US spreads propaganda in a foreign country, it is usually to get the people to align with US values as opposed to a goal of destabilization.
- xtian 6y agoThat’s deeply false. The US has engineered and provided support for coups around the world. Does that not count as destabilization?
- slg 6y ago>The US has engineered and provided support for coups around the world With the goal of allies gaining power. That is fundamentally different than Russian's initial goal of simply knocking the US out of their superpower role by causing polarization, internal strife, loss of faith in institutions, and just general chaos. I think people associate Russian disinformation as purely a right wing phenomenon because that is where they have had more success, but there is plenty of Russian disinformation targeted at and supporting the left wing too.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> With the goal of allies gaining power. That is fundamentally different than Russian's initial goal of simply knocking the US out of their superpower role Why do you think Russia is trying to knock the US out of its superpower of its superpower role? They’re not doing it just to be petty.
- slg 6y agoWho said they were doing it to be petty? They are doing it because we have a hostile relationship, not because they want to eventually be allies. There is a fundamental difference between let's interfere with this country to install a friendly government and let's interfere with this country so it rips itself apart.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI think there can be a difference in goals, but history strongly suggests no country has mastered the difference in outcomes, so regardless of which goal, attempts to do either should be held to the highest suspicion and probably censured by the international community. America learned a bloody and horrible lesson trying to install a friendly government in Afghanistan after Russia diminished their influence in the region.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI think it's worth noting that the wave of fascism that swept the world during the early 20th century coincided with radio and television being widely deployed. This may be correlation that does not imply causation. But demagogues had, for the first time, a way to reach into people's homes directly with their messages all the time, if they had access to microphones, video cameras, and broadcast towers. And it was a mechanism that excluded the ability of any antithesis messages to reach people on those same channels (once the government had control of the channels). Mussolini and his ilk certainly knew how to take advantage of these tools.
- alquemist 6y agoGoing further back, the Protestant Reformation was enabled by the spread of the printing press. In its wake, the 30 Years War. Upon utter exhaustion of the parties involved, the Peace of Westphalia set the stage for the modern nation states.
- claudeganon 6y agoAnd an often passed over part of the Protestant Reformation is that it was fueled by rabid anti-Semitism and scapegoating. Martin Luther wrote a 65,000 word treatise called “On the Jews and their Lies” that’s widely considered to have been the basis for Nazi ideology: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Luther_and_antisemitism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Luther_and_antisemiti...
- ficklepickle 6y agoI don't know why this is down voted, the link describes his later antisemitism in detail. Rabid is an apt descriptor.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "I think it's worth noting that the wave of fascism that swept the world during the early 20th century coincided with radio and television being widely deployed." Surely you mean both fascism and socialism?