3 ms·
When people talk about Apple having a monopoly they're referring to Apple having complete control over the sale of iOS software. There is no one else in that ma
by onion2k 6y ago
When people talk about Apple having a monopoly they're referring to Apple having complete control over the sale of iOS software. There is no one else in that market. Apple has 100% market share.
- dleslie 6y agoThere are other people in the _mobile software_ market; if the argument for monopoly requires being as specific as _mobile software that operates on a specific manufacturer of a minority of all phones_ then perhaps it's not a monopoly at all.
- shadowgovt 6y agoCorrect. The relevant terms are "horizontal monopoly" and "vertical monopoly." A horizontal monopoly is if one company made all the cars. A vertical monopoly is if one car manufacturer owned all the roads in Detroit and only their cars were authorized to drive on those roads. Apple is a vertical monopoly across its hardware, the software that runs on that hardware (they don't own the software, but they own the distribution channel), and some of the suppliers that manufacture components for the hardware.
- 52-6F-62 6y ago> A vertical monopoly is if one car manufacturer owned all the roads in Detroit and only their cars were authorized to drive on those roads. That's not a good analogy. It's more like if you bought X's car model and X had a policy that you could only buy official, certified parts from certified dealers through which they get a cut. (App Store) You can go for after market parts but if you break the car it's on you. ("Jailbreaking" AKA flashing your device)
- sixstringtheory 6y agoiOS is not a market, it’s a product. This is like saying Uber has a monopoly on all of their own assets. Wrong terminology.
- nodamage 6y agoSorry but a market consisting of a single manufacturer's own product is generally not considered a valid antitrust market for legal purposes. You can't simply declare an arbitrarily narrow market like this because every manufacturer would then have a monopoly over its own products.