3 ms·
"any intelligence agency naturally tries to compartmentalize as much as possible" Why is compartmentalization natural? The business world analog is "silos", an
by bediger4000 6y ago
"any intelligence agency naturally tries to compartmentalize as much as possible"
Why is compartmentalization natural? The business world analog is "silos", and we're forever trying to break them down, or work around them or something. Are intelligence agency compartments just jargon-justification for bureaucratic fiefdoms? We know human organizations tend towards individual small warring tribes, are compartments just a justification of that?
Would an intelligence agency that scraps compartmentalization have an advantage? How would you see that advantage?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Why is compartmentalization natural? Because intelligence agencies are always also concerned with counterintelligence as a major function. > The business world analog is "silos", and we're forever trying to break them down, or work around them or something. Most businesses try to keep highly sensitive data that has adverse consequences for release siloed. Unlike intelligence agencies, for most businesses such information is exceptional, rather than the rule. > Are intelligence agency compartments just jargon-justification for bureaucratic fiefdoms? They aren't just that, which is why the practice is universal. There is, of course, the perennial risk that the legitimate need gets exploited for that, though. > Would an intelligence agency that scraps compartmentalization have an advantage? As long as they were never penetrated by a hostile agency, maybe (though it might also reduce focus, contribute to analysis paralysis, and have other deleterious effects without penetration.) But the impacts of any penetration would be magnified, and while major penetrations may be rare because of compartmentalization, penetrations of intelligence agencies aren't rare enough for magnifying their impact to be discounted.