4 ms·
No we have fundamental disagreement about government debt. For clarity: There was absolutely zero need to go deeper into debt over COVID. Further, government
by Retric 6y ago
No we have fundamental disagreement about government debt. For clarity:
There was absolutely zero need to go deeper into debt over COVID. Further, government waste is not a question of debt without consequences. Paying people to fill out redundant forms or build pointless military hardware means those same highly skilled and capable people can’t being doing something of actual value.
Money is fundamentally an abstraction, and debt is simply another form of taxation. Debt as the least obvious form of taxation has illusionary benefit and real costs.
- kbenson 6y ago> No we have fundamental disagreement about government debt. Since I don't disagree with what you're saying, but also think it doesn't really apply to the specific point I was trying to express, I don't think we do. Apparently I'm just unable to adequately communicate my point. The only thing additional I can think to say is that you seem to making an argument about how government should be run, which is not what I'm arguing. I'm arguing what's required for our legislators to pass legislation on this today. Freeing up money from other sources is not one of those things, as they could borrow whatever extra they needed if they deemed it necessary.
- Retric 6y agoThat assumes two things, the legislature is absolutely willing to go into unlimited debt and they feel the change is critical not simply important/better etc. I don’t think those assumptions hold up in practice. Everything is a complex series of tradeoffs, not just in what’s useful but also in public perception.