3 ms·
I would also add that the word is very different Han 50 years ago. Some things have gotten very cheap, some things have stayed the same price. So the technolog
by epistasis 6y ago
I would also add that the word is very different Han 50 years ago. Some things have gotten very cheap, some things have stayed the same price.
So the technology that looked good, theoretically, in 1970 may not have the same outlook in 2020.
In particular, France's failing attempt is the EPR. There have been construction starts at three sites, and all have been massive off schedule. For the three not in China, they have been massively over budget. The build in China was the third to be started, but is the only one completed; planned construction time was 48 months, but it ended up taking twice as long. I don't know how to judge the pricing of construction in China, but if the Western world could do it in 8 years and at the stated cost of $7.5B, it would be a fantastic deal.
What has changed since the last time? I don't know. Maybe different sorts of people go into the same jobs. Maybe executive culture is to blame. Maybe engineering culture is to blame. Maybe procurement and construction is to blame. Nobody has provided a solid explanation of X, Y, and Z with concrete examples.
Some will say regulations are different and the cause, but at the same time nobody says that these are unnecessary regulations, or that there's a smarter path that would make them cheap, it's always just vague accusations without any specific call to action.
- vilhelm_s 6y agoI mean, you began this thread by saying that they've added a new regulation on waste heat and nobody knows how to build a cooling system that satisfies it. Maybe we can begin by repealing that one and go from there...
- epistasis 6y agoWe know how to build cooling towers. That's the $7B cost. Why would we remove a common sense environmental regulation, when we can build cheaper better things that have less environmental damage? Why the obsession with nuclear, at any cost? What is the benefit and gain when we have cheaper better alternatives? What was considered "cheap" in the 1980s is no longer the cheapest option. We have better, cheaper technologies. And on top of that the US can no longer build big things. We don't have construction management competence.
- cbmuser 6y agoBecause renewables don’t help reduce emissions as much as nuclear does. Renewables need fossile backup plants. Go on electricitymap.org and see how Germany has among the highest emissions in the electricity sector in Europe despite 50% renewables in their electricity mix.
- roenxi 6y ago> when we can build cheaper better things that have less environmental damage? No we can't. The plans are to build nuclear plants that do exactly no environmental or social damage. Solar/wind/etc can't possibly compete to that standard. Try reliably isolating solar panel waste from the biosphere for even a century and see how much it costs. The figures would be too absurd to consider, which is why nobody is suggesting it. I'd be happy to go with the cheapest thing if everything was to the same standard; but solar seems to getting a free pass that nuclear isn't, because people care about having to evacuate an area but have no fear of heavy metals poisoning. For reasons that continue to baffle the rationalists.
- epistasis 6y ago> The plans are to build nuclear plants that do exactly no environmental or social damage. Solar/wind/etc can't possibly compete to that standard. I'm not sure if you're serious with post. "No" environmental damage, when we have to mine uranium, iron ore, and massive amounts of concrete? Yet somehow they "waste" of old solar panels is hazardous to the biosphere and impossible to separate? Nuclear waste is far more hazardous and we don't seem to have much problem isolating that in France. And then you say that solar is getting a free pass, when you invent issues for solar that are far more difficult for nuclear to handle? How is this rational in any way?
- pas 6y agoThe question is energy density and economics. Can solar/wind with the same environmental impact per kWh become cheaper than nuclear? Maybe it's already cheaper. Who knows. So far no one has really pointed at data in this thread.
- cbmuser 6y agoAgain, it’s not a technological problem. It’s the West of being unable to finish large projects on time. China and Russia are building new reactors faster and faster because in these countries nuclear never had a strong political opposition.
- pas 6y agoBecause the projects are started before they should have been. The permitting process should be a lot more final, the construction process should be monitored, and unless it exceeds some metric (too loud, too polluting, too costly), it shouldn't be stoppable just by simply filing a motion in court. Of course the plans should be a lot more rigorous. And then of course prices would go up. But cost overruns would go down. Also, the fact that "the West" has stopped its building boom led to the construction industry atrophying. There is no efficiency, because there's no scale.