4 ms·
> "Couldn't find external investors despite very generous guaranteed pricing for its energy." UK is a world leader in finding particularly sadomasochistic ways
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
> "Couldn't find external investors despite very generous guaranteed pricing for its energy."
UK is a world leader in finding particularly sadomasochistic ways of financing critical infrastructure. This is like the PFI debacle all over again. Interest rates are at zero, the government should take out the cheque book and finance the plant directly. You can absolutely just buy a reactor and they are being built in China at record pace.
Private investment contributes nothing of value to this type of project, because spesification, location, and everything else was already decided
It only accrues extra cost because of higher interest rates avaliable to private investors and risk hedging. All the current government is trying to do, is keep the cost of the powerplants off the book, and hiding it from the national debt.
- epistasis 6y agoBut why would the government want to provide the loans, when it is already providing a massive subsidy on pricing to guarantee good returns, which should be far more valuable to a buildable technology? The reason, of course, is that nuclear is not very buildable, and nobody is willing to make a bet, even with very high returns. If private investors would rather invest in offshore wind, or storage, why should the UK government be less wise with its money? If the UK is going to take on billion debt for energy infrastructure (an excellent idea in my opinion that would benefit the UK greatly!) it should invest in more sound and reliable sources of energy like renewables, that have a proven track record of being built on time and in budget. And technologies where we learn when we build so that next year's project is even cheaper.
- cbmuser 6y agoRenewables _always_ require a fossile backup. You are _not_ fixing the climate with just renewables. Look at electricitymap.org and compare the emissions of Germany (50% renewables) with France (70% nuclear). Germany is 7 times dirtier in its electricity sector. I don’t understand why people keep repeating that non-sense that renewables reduce emissions at large scale, they don’t. And building NPPs fast is no problem, look at China and Russia. Heck, Japan used to build new plants in just about three years.
- toyg 6y agoAh yes, let’s use the last country to see a massive nuclear disaster as a model. That will end well! /s We’d need less “dirty” backups if we invested more in batteries.
- ezzaf 6y agoThat's simply untrue. Iceland for example is already 100% renewable. Other grids with large installed hydro generation (eg New Zealand) could move to solely renewable with the installation of more intermittent generation and transmission infrastructure. Yes, most grids still rely on non renewable resources. But that is simply a relic of the fact that they were built that way. The existing examples prove it's possible.
- kortilla 6y agoThat’s the equivalent of saying “be born rich” to a poor person. Iceland is running on geothermal which most places don’t have and dams are a non-starter in the vast majority of river systems due to the ecological destruction. There are no countries running on wind/solar, which is the only renewable technology that can actually run everywhere.
- oblio 6y agoIceland also has the population of a small to midsized city (~300k, if I recall correctly).
- ezzaf 6y agoThe comment I was replying to stated that "Renewables _always_ require a fossil backup". This is clearly untrue, as the multiple examples of grids that do not have or need fossil backup shows. Certainly the examples I have given are those that have the easiest path to renewables. It is entirely logical that they would be the first to transition. But it proves that it's possible.
- Aerroon 6y agoHydroelectric power isn't quite as clean as many believe though. >We estimate that GHG emissions from reservoir water surfaces account for 0.8 (0.5–1.2) Pg CO2 equivalents per year, with the majority of this forcing due to CH4. https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/66/11/949/2754271 https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/66/11/949/275427... That's between 2% and 3% of our global greenhouse gas emissions. About three quarters of greenhouse gas emissions come from energy production and about 15% of all energy production is hydro power if I recall correctly. It's much better than fossil fuels, but not quite clean.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoBecause subsidy is an idiotic way to fund it. What's the point of seeking private investment if the government guarantees profit, selects the reactor design and it's location? What usefull funcrion do private investors fullfill, their funding is more expensive than a government loan. They should contract EDF to build it for a fixed price, job done.
- epistasis 6y agoThe point is that it motivates the builder to complete it in a certain amount of time, not just at some time in the future. However, that induces too much risk apparently. In the US most contested have been for a fixed price, it's just that nobody meets that fixed price nor the schedule. And since nuclear front-loads 50 years of generation prices into the construction, Amy delay at all I'm starting service is a financial disaster.
- jariel 6y agoPrinting money is not magic. Anyone can do it, if it's important enough, it will get built. It's not actually the cost - it's the politics of it, and all the very ugly surrounding externalities.