4 ms·
Didn't buy his responses to "What About Volatility?" and "What About Crashes?" He talked about averages of historical data that include crashes. Sure. But con
by JKCalhoun 6y ago
Didn't buy his responses to "What About Volatility?" and "What About Crashes?"
He talked about averages of historical data that include crashes. Sure.
But consider the window within the throes of a crash. Someone who always has and continues to spend a fixed amount every year will greatly diminish their capital during those lean years of the market.
An exaggerated hypothetical to make the point:
If they have $500K @ 5% and take out $32K a year, they can go over 30 years on their nest egg.
If their nest egg falls to $100K due to a market crash, they have three years of their nest egg left.
- neogodless 6y agoHistorically, over any 30 year span, has there been an 80% drop in market value, or a huge drop that was not preceded by a bull market? What exact sequence would have to occur for this hypothetical to have lost 80% in market value and be stuck in a market that doesn't recover quickly? By most historical averages, after 20 years the hypothetical portfolio has grown to $2 million inflation-adjusted, which means a drop to $100k or $250k would be a whopping 87.5%+ crash. On the flip side, a prolonged bear market in the first few years are the worst case scenario, though for most early retirees, the choices are to ignore the "fixed 5%" and/or seek additional income, if the sequence of returns really are dire enough.
- gshdg 6y agoIt doesn't matter whether the market stays up over 30 years. If it crashes at the wrong time (especially if that's after you've retired) and you have 100K left, you have only 3 years to recover, not 30. And even if the market recovers in 3 years, by then you're left with a fraction of your capital.
- AstralStorm 6y agoYet worse outcome is when you actually need the money (say, medical emergency or required big purchase) and you don't have it because market is lean or illiquid. And if you're old and retired, you will likely not get the needed loan. At the same moment, you don't have a job and if the emergency is big enough, you might not be able to get one. Even if you keep yourself updated to meet the needs of the market (which does cost money) others may not believe you. Face it, it's temporal gambling also known as a martingale. One with ok odds but still gambling. There are classes of assets that are less vulnerable to such downturns, but they have their own risks. (Mostly properties you live in and transportation you use.)
- proverbialbunny 6y agoAt the "wrong time" meaning you're at end of life, yah? By that time you're collecting SSI and have medicare. When you're really old you have less of a reason to spend, so even with a nice house that is paid off it becomes easy to not dip into retirement funds if needed. Btw, 5% is not a safe withdrawal percent unless you're really old. Most do 4% and aim to not diminish but increase their savings in the long run while retired.
- neogodless 6y agoBad hypothetical situations are bad. But have you looked at the data? Historically, you're much more likely to have your money grow over time, such that it's much higher before a big crash, and you have ample capital to wait out a bear market. Again, the only scenarios that resulted in running out of capital in a 4% withdrawal rate happened in the very first few years, retiring right before a very bad series of years. If early retirement is your goal, and especially if you're a competent software developer, if the market is that bad early on (which is very rare) then you just have to change course and go back to work.
- charwalker 6y agoWhich, other than not electing a GOP president and Congress, can't be predicted beyond rough cycles. It's scary, it's hypothetical, and combined with basic social safety nets in place today are unlikely to sink a FIRE plan that is robust. That isn't a political statement about the GOP, it's close to fact. When did we last not enter a recession, or the possibilities of one, after the GOP held Congress and the White House? Trump, Bush, Bush Sr/Reagan. Its like part of the plan is to drive the nation broke after concentrating wealth with donors and friends/family.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoWell, it stands to reason if you make the rich wealthier and everyone else poorer, there is no one to buy goods and stimulate the economy.
- 0x6862 6y agoYou increase your defensive assets (bonds, term deposits, annuities etc.) as you become more risk adverse (closer to retirement or other change in circumstances). So when a 90% crash occurs that takes 10 years to recover you’re either still earning, or you can draw down on your defensive assets, letting your stocks recover
- gshdg 6y agoHave you even seen the returns on bonds and cash equivalents lately?
- AstralStorm 6y agoDefensive assets such as fully owning a place to live and means to travel, you mean? Or perhaps tools of the trade? Bonds are not defensive enough. The about only way to lose a place to live you actually own is to live in a warzone or get very deep in debt... The old adage is to not gamble your life on being able to pay a debt. This is rather hard in the USA due to completely broken economics of medicine, education and real estate, but in other places, much more available.
- thedufer 6y agoThe response to "what about volatility" is not really right. Volatility makes a much bigger difference than the article admits - the reason FIRE proponents come up with a similar number is because they started with a much higher number. They are using US-only historical returns, which average around 7% (inflation-adjusted), not 5%, and the safe withdrawal rate is typically quoted as 3.5%-4%. So in order to be safe, you have to cut the return rate in half or so. There's probably an argument to be made that this is still too aggressive, because US historical returns feels like cherrypicking - they're much better than international returns, and there doesn't seem to be a good argument for expecting that to continue. That said - how many 80% drops are there? If your criteria for safety is "will have enough money to last forever even if the great depression hits the second I retire", you might be a bit too conservative - it's hard to imagine another great depression at all, given the Fed's recent history of propping up the market in crashes, let alone at the worst possible time. You'll never be able to take chances on anything with requirements like that.
- bumby 6y ago>it's hard to imagine another great depression at all, given the Fed's recent history of propping up the market in crashes I think the counter-argument (not that I know enough one way or the other) is that the Fed’s recent addiction to low interest rates removes one of its most important tools for propping up the economy if the existing approach is found insufficient
- thedufer 6y agoThe strategy this spring of just buying up bonds en masse worked pretty well, and seems fairly unlimited as long as they're willing to print money with which to buy stuff. They have a lot more levers than just interest rates.
- bumby 6y agoWhat types of bonds are you referring to? Treasury bonds aren’t exactly going gang busters. Or maybe we’re talking about different periods? The point I was trying to make (maybe unclearly) is that one of the main bullets to assist the broad economy may have already been fired. To your point, there will always be segments of the economy that perform well, but that’s not equivalent to the broad economy performing well
- JackMorgan 6y agoThere's a famous study called the Trinity Study, wherein the authors posit that based on all historical evidence, for a 30 year withdrawal, 4% is a safe number to be able to continuing withdrawals for the whole 30 years. Extending it to 60 years requires dropping down to 3.5%. However, if one is content "leaning down" the fun spending in lean years, those percentages can go up a little bit on average. See the literature about VPW for more info: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Variable_percentage_withdrawal https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Variable_percentage_withdraw...
- JKCalhoun 6y agoBogleheads (flashes the secret handsign) ... I'm in.