4 ms·
You say "political flamewar", I say "pertinent fact about both the article and contemporary politics, stated with some editorial spin but not excessively so".
by samatman 6y ago
You say "political flamewar", I say "pertinent fact about both the article and contemporary politics, stated with some editorial spin but not excessively so".
I didn't know about the Aliso Canyon gas leak, or that Kamala Harris was Attorney General at the time (and apparently did nothing about it).
I'm quite sure you canned this because of your commitment to quality discourse, not out of a desire to memory-hole something important about a candidate in a hotly contested election. Nonetheless, you did both, and I'd like you to show a lighter hand in future.
- dang 6y agoThere's plenty of opportunity to discuss pertinent facts without flamebait. Threads are most sensitive to their initial conditions. If the initial condition is a blanket inflammatory statement about $group, the resulting thread isn't likely to illuminate anything. Fortunately it's entirely unnecessary to comment that way, so we can have other kinds of discussion. Admittedly this is all subject to interpretation and reasonable people interpret these things differently. I appreciate your not jumping to the accusation of bias that usually comes up in these cases. The way I look at it, HN's influence on politics is negligible but politics' influence on HN is existential, and our first responsibility is to protect the container here.
- bgorman 6y agoWith all due respect, my OP contained a relevant anecdote (Largest methane gas leak in US history, also in southern California). I didn't say whether democrats are good or bad, I just asserted that they don't care, and I offered the relevant anecdote about how the attorney general who reviewed the previous methane gas leak has continued to ascend in politics, while no criminal charges have been filed. I think many people are probably not aware of the additional context I have brought to this situation, and I certainly think it is notable given the thread. I would like to know why exactly you think my post is flamebait. I expressed a single opinion, not saying if it is good or bad result - and provided evidence to support my opinion. Plenty of people make posts on Hackernews like "Facebook doesn't respect user privacy" - which is obviously controversial. I cannot help but feel like my post was singled out because some people think that the objective truths in my post are inconvenient.
- dang 6y agoInflammatory generalizations like "California Democrats simply do not care about the environment" are garden-variety political flamebait.
- bgorman 6y agoI appreciate you taking the time to provide a nuanced and thoughtful reply to my question
- dang 6y agoI take that as meaning that I came across as dismissive. Sorry! I would have been happy to add to it, but I couldn't think of anything else to say. Does it really seem otherwise to you? Any statement of the form "$group simply do not care about $good" is going to land as flamebait.