3 ms·
I think ideally there might be powerful features of the tool that take some time learning, and that's okay. But the tool itself should have simple features tha
by jrochkind1 6y ago
I think ideally there might be powerful features of the tool that take some time learning, and that's okay.
But the tool itself should have simple features that can be used by a newcomer too. The tool itself should not be "overwhelming and difficult to understand" -- I mean "overwhelming" is never a plus, is it? The power-user features should be designed in such a way they don't scare off or interfere with more basic use. Rather, the basic use should be low-barrier, and serve as a step to investing to learn the more challenging use.
"simple things should be simple, complex things should be possible." (Alan Kay). Not "everything should be hard and complex because we are resigned that that's the only way to make complex things possible."
I think this is true as a general rule, but it may also depend on the "product" (whether commercial or noncommercial like wikipedia). There may be some products where it's okay if you scare off newcomers, where you know you have a core that will be willing to invest the time to figure out a challenging or even "overwhelming" tool because of it's value to them, and that's all you need/want. But I don't think that's appropriate for wikipedia, I think it is the absolutely correct choice and in line with wikipedia's mission to prioritize making basic wikipedia use as low-barrier as possible for as many users as possible.
- Robotbeat 6y agoSo I think Wikipedia's bar for use is pretty low. To bring it much lower (i.e. to Twitter or Facebook levels) might reduce quality because people will be more willing to make changes while requiring even less time investment. Wikipedia has wildly succeeded and mostly avoided the fate of other social media sites. We must tread very carefully to keep Wikipedia for future generations.
- jrochkind1 6y agoSo these particular changes are more about the UI for viewing/consuming content than editing/creating. And I'm suspicious of the theory that a harder to use UI for editing results in higher quality content. I understand your theory that some people who would edit content maliciously or without proper care would be put off by a harder to use UI, but it's not obvious to me that it's true, or that it wouldn't be countered by putting off even more people who would have good intentions and take proper care, some of whom correct malicious content. When making decisions for a site that millions use, you probably don't want to make significant strategic decisions, like to intentionally not make the UI as easy to use as you can, based on hunches. But anyway, wikipedians have actually had the opposite concern of yours for a while, rather than increasing to "too many" contributors, wikipedia seems to be losing contributors, and many see it as a problem. Both because you need enough contributors to maintain content, and because the self-image of wikipedia is that "anyone can edit", they actually want to make it accessible, not put barriers in the way. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Why_is_Wikipedia_losing_contributors_-_Thinking_about_remedies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Why_is_Wikipedia_los... More info about who contributes to wikipedia is on the following page, which suggests about 132K users in the last 30 days. I don't know what the number is for how many users viewed wikipedia in the last 30 days but I'd guess far under 1% of wikipedia users make edits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Who_writes_Wikipedia%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Who_writes_Wikipedia...
- sjy 6y agoMuch of the discussion in your first link seems very old. There is a link buried in there to this discussion in 2015, when it was suggested that the trend may be reversing (based on the questionable decision to focus on “active” editors making more than 100 edits a month). It would be surprising if the growth in internet use over the past decade had not increased the number of Wikipedia editors at all. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2015-08-26/In_focus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2... I’m suspicious too, but I agree with the grandparent that we should tread very carefully. Wikipedia’s success probably has at least something to do with the fact that its development has been extremely slow and isolated from commercial web development trends.
- Robotbeat 6y agoi agree wth you. i was just providing a potential reason why making it easiercould be hazardous (just like makin it harder could be). Wikipedia is such a special thing and we don't totally understand why it has worked.