10 ms·
Recycling Capital: The Key To The Startup Economy
- laujen 16y agoI'm in Portland, Oregon, and think this is actually the biggest problem with our start-up culture. There just aren't enough people who have been there/done that before that are investing in the next generation. There are investors around and the government has stepped in to fund some investment groups to bridge the gap, but until we have a round of winners really supporting the next round of companies I think our community will struggle.
- colinyoung 16y agoIn Chicago, where I'm located, this is our core problem too. It's all about that first round of winners. I think startup scenes really launch after the employees from the first big win sell _their_ companies.
- laujen 16y agoWe actually had some winners in the 90s but many of them either lost their winnings in the dot bomb or never invested in other companies. A few of those winners are guiding their second or third start-ups, too.
- colinyoung 16y agoDefinitely. The main reason they didn't reinvest was timing -- everyone was burnt out on startups even if they had won after the dot.com burst. But now, FB or Google employees are like, wow, that was awesome, let's do it again. I think the startup scene is more mature now and that reinvestment is more likely to happen outside of SV now -- the key difference is that startups are more stable, wiser, far leaner, and more `cool' now, so it's seen as an actually "safe" bet to re-invest. I know if I ever had a win that's exactly what I would do, in fact being able to re-invest is a lot of my motivation for being a founder.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- asanwal 16y agoThe data for Illinois is already looking up based on VC activity. The Halo Effect that Groupon will enable should be a good thing for Chicago. Look at page 15 of this report which shows an uptick for Illinois - http://bit.ly/hdL5Yz http://bit.ly/hdL5Yz. Of course, 2 quarters doesn't make a long-term trend but it's a start so hopefully lots of good things will emerge from Chicago and the virtuous cycle will start.
- luminary 16y agoThis is quite true. My Portland State advisor (ex-Bay Areaite) and his friends and angle investing everywhere but Portland. On a side note: any Bay Area Portlanders on HN?
- laujen 16y agoThat's a shame because there is some really interesting stuff happening around town.
- fnazeeri 16y agoFred Wilson is one of a very small group of investors that has actually achieved any exits to recycle. The problem isn't that investors aren't recycling their returns, it's that they aren't making any returns. So the next thought is that investors are somehow to blame, but no. It's entrepreneurs who aren't creating businesses that generate good investments. The core problem here is that we need to create more good businesses.
- zzleeper 16y agoWhat I found pretty disturbing is that this type of reinvesting (keeping everything in startups, reinvesting 100%), is very similar to the patterns seen in Ponzi schemes. (The basic idea is that if everyone reinvests everything, then bubbles are VERY easy to sustain) Now, I don't have a clue on whether this is a bubble or not, just pointing out this curious pattern
- stretchwithme 16y agoAs I read this, I couldn't help but think of how much better real investing is for the overall economy than government stimulus. When the government spends money on make-work projects solely to stimulate the economy (with no actual benefit for the public), that capital is gone. Nothing is returned to the people who provided it. And there is no gain. Its not compounding over time. Someone ate it all up. That means less overall wealth. That capital wasn't preserved. It cannot be invested again and again and again like wisely invested capital.
- trevelyan 16y agoWhen Keynes picked his example of stimulus, the analogy he choose was paying people to bury money in mine shafts and dig it up again. The reason he chose this is that it makes stimulus logically identical to what happens under the gold standard without it: society puts effort into digging up more when the total amount of gold in circulation falls. So as long as the economy is facing deflation, it isn't hard to see that stimulus is at worst the conceptual equivalent of doing nothing. And it is usually much better because it funds activities with a bigger collective payoff than moving dirt back and forth. And it prevents mass unemployment! Standard caveats apply that this only holds in deflationary conditions, and monetary policy is usually preferred where possible. But it isn't hard to see that stimulus isn't intended to compete with private investment, and actually enables it in many situations. Especially since holding cash (or buying gold) is often preferred to other investments when the currency is falling, interest rates are low and the economic outlook is otherwise dismal.
- stretchwithme 16y agoI disagree. Its the collapse of the Keynesian housing bubble that's causing the current unemployment. Keynesians ignore where the money for their spending comes from. It can only come from taxes or borrowing, both of which make less capital available for the private sector. Instead of allowing the phony economy die, they seek to keep it going. As if building more houses than we can afford somehow creates wealth, instead of putting hundreds of billions of our debt to sit and rot. And replacing the judgement of millions of people actually spending their own money with the judgements of short-term oriented politicians that haven't worked for the money they spend and who are actively trying to fool us most of the time is not going to result in smarter investments. The government loves to make waves on the pond, call attention to the highs and distract you from the lows. But no new water is created. And when the instability they create knocks boats over, they claim no one could have seen it coming. All the splashing around is just magnifying the distortions.
- khsdf7 16y agoThis blog post is SO New Yorker. It is the height of arrogance to pass off what is, like it or not, a form of gambling, an expression of greed, as a philanthropic, altruistic gesture. I know as well as anyone here that this is one of the engines of the economy, but come on. Everyone is playing the same game, and you happen to be good at it. Don't insult our intelligence.