7 ms·
I wonder if Intel is aware that the Atom brand is pretty sullied. I'm surprised they haven't rebranded it. They've had some decent ones, like the C3000, but peo
by tyingq 6y ago
I wonder if Intel is aware that the Atom brand is pretty sullied. I'm surprised they haven't rebranded it. They've had some decent ones, like the C3000, but people do associate the name with underwhelming performance.
- slezyr 6y agoAnd awful Linux support. Many people with x86 tablets hate them.
- zozbot234 6y agoLinux support for x86 tablets has improved a lot as of late. There are a few problematic chipsets, e.g. with PowerVR based graphics, but they're rare.
- MisterTea 6y agoThe PowerVR issue was much bigger when netbooks were all the rave. They were usually sold with XP Home running on 256-512MB RAM which was barley enough to run the base OS let alone a single program. The first thought was to toss Linux on the system but you were immediately thwarted by missing graphics drivers. So you had to run in vesa mode resulting in worse performance than Windows XP. Shame because a friend had a nice Toshiba that was completely useless from the day he bought it and wound up tossing it after just a year. So many useless netbooks...
- ClikeX 6y agoThis. I don't think someone designing an ATM cares if the CPU can run Crysis.
- paulmd 6y agoI can't speak to your tablet use-case but as a general statement Atom is absolutely fine, even great under linux. Intel actually has long had some of the better Linux support in the market in general, especially when compared to the early Zen hardware which needed a few years to build up critical mass (and of course it dumps all over the ARM-based experience, having a non-x86 processor is several notches upwards in complexity/difficulty of the experience). In particular they were an early mover on the open-source graphics driver thing (several years ahead of AMD), and their Linux driver has been the gold standard for stability/specs compliance for a long time. The chips underneath them aren't the fastest but the driver is clean and sensible.
- chungus_khan 6y agoThe era where it was bad though, it was phenomenally bad. Before the present era of Intel-designed graphics cores in Atom chips there was a range of atom chips in some netbooks and tablets that used PowerVR graphics, and these machines were absolute horror shows.
- paulmd 6y agoFair enough, I guess that's the difference then. I've always used the ones with Intel graphics.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- PaulHoule 6y agoThe Atom is like the 737 MAX. American car manufacturers have shown no interest at all in selling small cars but have been forced to by regulators. Thus the Nova, Chevette, Cobalt, Sonic, Neon, Gremlin and other names you don't remember. Honda and Toyota could not stop making the Civic and Corolla if they tried -- if they did stop for a year they would see people buying 3 year old cars at new prices and be shocked at the money they are leaving on the table. (Honda in particular has been trying to phase out the Fit for the CR-V but they may not have the discipline to be able to do it.) Atom is a Chevy Nova that is being marketed as if it were a Toyota Corolla. Crap like that should be forgotten in six months, not waved around to remind you how bad it is.
- projektfu 6y agoI remember the chevette being a very popular car that was partly responsible for bridging GM out of a sales slump in the 70s. Two oil shocks did a real number on the market for heavy cars.
- bluGill 6y agoI'm not really old enough to remember, but as I recall the chevette was sold at a slight loss because it got the fleet fuel mileage numbers up allowing GM to sell more expensive gas guzzlers. Of course profit is weird and it is hard to account for everything.
- jacquesm 6y agoThe Chevette was hugely popular in Europe as marketed by Opel and Vauxhall, part of the GM empire. Effectively it was an Opel sold in the US rather than an American car sold in Europe.
- kube-system 6y agoThe Sonic is also an Opel designed platform. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM_Gamma_platform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM_Gamma_platform
- 6y ago
- jmt_ 6y agoI agree that the Atom brand has been sullied, but I've often wondered if they weren't "bad" per se but were used in the wrong kinds of products. I got the impression they were better suited for an ATM or a vending machine that Tweets or something -- but not great for a full Windows environment, even if the user is not doing anything resource heavy. Feel similarly toward Celeron. Marketing != practical use for these CPUs IMO
- tyingq 6y agoYeah, they have used it all over. Including the C2XXX and C3XXX for server platforms.
- mbreese 6y agoI used to have an Atom based server that was used for an SSH bastion for a rack-internal IPMI/LOM network and it worked great. But that’s literally all it was used for. Sometimes it’s nice to have a small server for a dedicated purpose. But would I have considered an Atom for anything else? No way. Then again, I also didn’t consider anything but an Atom for this job.
- mlyle 6y agoFor me, it's getting hard to consider anything other than Pi for these kinds of tasks. Yes, I could install an ancient, low-spec machine, but it'd use more power and be more bother. Biggest reason this is annoying is only one onboard ethernet.
- mbreese 6y agoNow that you can boot a Pi from USB, I could see this point of view. I’ve had enough SDs die on me in a Pi that I wouldn’t trust an SD driven Pi for anything where I’d need to rely on it for remote access. I wish there was something in between Pi and Atom for this use case.
- smileybarry 6y ago
- trynumber9 6y agoYes, that's why they brand some of the top SKUs Pentium and Celeron. But these are for embedded uses where branding is less important than actual features/performance.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ip26 6y agoOn the other hand, it could be a form of price anchoring for their more expensive chips. In which case, a slightly tarnished reputation is actually a plus.
- tyingq 6y agoPerhaps. It's confusing though, that there are Atom server chips that are complete garbage, then some that actually pretty decent.
- 0xEFF 6y agoI use an atom C2558 as a file server. It runs under 15 watts, has no fan, 32 GB of ECC memory, quad gigabit Ethernet ports and runs ESXi hosting a Debian ZFS file server. It’s perfectly balanced. It can read and write at full gigabit speed, with ZFS encryption, and the CPU is ~90% utilized.
- rubatuga 6y agoI’m pretty sure an intel atom cannot reach gigabit speeds with zfs encryption.
- jeffbee 6y agoBased on? Have you ever used one? They have hardware AES, and have had since 2013.
- tyingq 6y agoThat's part of the confusion. The C2XXX and C3XXX aren't typical Atoms. They use the brand for an odd range of chips.
- wmf 6y agoI always thought the C series should have been branded as something like Xeon E1 to indicate that they're server chips. And now Intel has changed it up again with Snow Ridge branded as E5900 instead of C4XXX.
- 0xEFF 6y agoI'm not making it up: https://gist.github.com/jeffmccune/0f381a69e0a8111c3cac882911062923 https://gist.github.com/jeffmccune/0f381a69e0a8111c3cac88291... WRITE: bw=184MiB/s (193MB/s), 184MiB/s-184MiB/s (193MB/s-193MB/s), io=10.8GiB (11.6GB), run=60067-60067msec Correction from above though, it's an Atom C2758
- flyinghamster 6y agoI think it's the early versions that tarnished Atom's name. I have an ancient Atom 330 still chugging away as my Asterisk box. It's on an old Intel Mini-ITX board, the only Intel-branded motherboard I've ever had that didn't die from capacitor plague. It's hilarious to realize that a Raspberry Pi 4 will run circles around it. The 330 can't saturate a GbE port, and even the SSD pokes along at the 1.5 Gbps SATA speed. If I didn't have a PCI telephony card I wanted to keep, I'd replace it with a Pi.
- jeffbee 6y agoAmong who? Not the people to whom they market these parts. People who are designing embedded systems with 24 low-power cores and integrated programmable 100gbps NICs don't care if the people on some overclocker forum don't like the Atom brand.
- robotnikman 6y agoI think the defect which causes Atom C2000 processors to fail after 18 months comes to mind, to both businesses that bought the equipment and the equipment manufacturers that used them.
- sumtechguy 6y agoThis batch of chips looks like it was designed for someone in mind that was going to buy a bunch of them. They then tossed it over the wall and said others can get it too. Probably some sort of IoT type situation where power is a concern with an occasional burst of work. Something where you are 95% idle and then that 5% you want a bit of perf within a particular power budget. Something like a TV, cablebox, or a wake up sample send data in goto sleep situation.
- jackac 6y agoThey are probably referring to pre-silvermont(pre-2013) which were in-order execution.
- dboreham 6y agoIn the target market "Atom" means "low cost" which is exactly what Intel wants.
- jeffbee 6y agoThis isn't right, either. In Intel's lineup the Atom brand is the most expensive brand using these cores. The Pentium and Celeron branded parts are the cheaper and cheapest ones, repsectively. "Atom" is basically the "Xeon" of its family.
- philjohn 6y agoI see it more as "really low power". I've got a quad core Atom mini PC running plex and general file-server duties, and the thing is not only passive but sips energy.