3 ms·
What is “sentence flavor?” I’ve never heard the term. You seem to be using it to justify the inclusion of irrelevant details as if that makes a sentence “taste”
by cgriswald 6y ago
What is “sentence flavor?” I’ve never heard the term. You seem to be using it to justify the inclusion of irrelevant details as if that makes a sentence “taste” differently. Well, irrelevant details don’t make for very interesting writing and usually people don’t scatter words over their sentences like bacon bits over a salad unless they’re writing terrible fiction.
So maybe the word is relevant. It’s not obvious to me what the relevance is, so asking seems pretty logical. Otherwise a reader is forced to conclude that it somehow has to do with white, presumably Australian stereotypes.
Likewise, if Perth is included it clues the reader into a more specific area which might tell us something or not, depending on our pre-existing knowledge of Perth. No reader is going to conclude that the detail Perth was added merely for “flavor” and has no other significance. They might not have asked even if ignorant, because they might’ve made their own assumptions (e.g. this is an area where the trees can be found), but they wouldn’t assume it was a meaningless detail.
And yes, I think I might have asked about relevance if the poster had said, “My roommates, while wearing purple t-shirts, told me...”
When you add in the baggage that comes with race and racial stereotypes are you really surprised anyone asked? You don’t even have to be offended to not understand why race was included.
- TecoAndJix 6y agoThanks for your response. I think I tried to be too creative and should have just said descriptive words or adjectives. You make a good point on the baggage that race and racial stereotypes have - that is why I asked the question! I wanted to stimulate conversation on using color as a descriptive term and if the users question came from the sensitivity (from the baggage and stereotypes you mentioned) of mentioning color, the fact it’s the only descriptor, or a combination of both. You also make a good point with the purple shirt example but wonder if that oddity would have really compelled a response. My question came from genuine curiosity and desire for discussion and hoped it would be received us such!