4 ms·
>I don't think you'll be able to attribute that quote to me. Eich fucked up, and should have realized that you can't be leading a flagship of diversity on the o
by coldtea 6y ago
>I don't think you'll be able to attribute that quote to me. Eich fucked up, and should have realized that you can't be leading a flagship of diversity on the one hand and be a bigot on the other
Who asked Mozilla to be a "flagship of diversity"? What we wanted off them, and what their mission statement was, is a FOSS browser that supported the open web.
Plus, one can be/believe whatever on their personal life, as long as they don't bring it to the office.
Not to mention that penalizing people because they supported one side in a public vote is anti-democratic.
- jacquesm 6y agoNobody asked, but Mozilla took (and still takes) that role. Witness plenty of comments on HN from Mozilla employees reinforcing that. I'm all for the FOSS browser company, the 'support for the open web' is already a step in the direction of losing focus. Just keeping up and having a viable alternative browser out there keeping Chrome at bay is a major job (and one they are currently miserably failing at). > Not to mention that penalizing people because they supported one side in a public vote is anti-democratic. Actually, it isn't. Actions have consequences, if Eich wanted to be a contributor to that cause he could have done so silently. By doing it in a publicly visible way as the CEO of a large company he made it a political statement and action begets reaction. Eich very explicitly brought his views into the office in a way that a substantial fraction of Mozilla's employees did not want to be associated with. Besides that, money in politics is anti-democratic.
- lkdsajflkfdsjg 6y ago> Nobody asked, but Mozilla took (and still takes) that role. Witness plenty of comments on HN from Mozilla employees reinforcing that. Then those employees are part of the problem!
- koolba 6y ago> Actually, it isn't. Actions have consequences, if Eich wanted to be a contributor to that cause he could have done so silently. By doing it in a publicly visible way as the CEO of a large company he made it a political statement and action begets reaction. Eich very explicitly brought his views into the office in a way that a substantial fraction of Mozilla's employees did not want to be associated with. He didn't bring his views into the office. He had them outside and the alphabet mob lit them as a Molotov cocktail and threw them into the building. Those employees could have quit and worked somewhere else too. In a lot of ways that would have been great as they could have cut down on a couple of the pointless projects. By your standard it's impossible for anyone to both have public views that disagree with your own and be the head of any large organization. > Besides that, money in politics is anti-democratic. Money in politics is the great equalizer. It's as democratic as it gets. Otherwise you end up with a handful of media and tech oligarchs controlling all messaging.
- jacquesm 6y ago> He didn't bring his views into the office. He had them outside and the alphabet mob lit them as a Molotov cocktail and threw them into the building. He made a public donation in his own name to a very divisive cause. That is a political statement if there ever was one and set the stage for a confrontation with at least a sizeable fraction of the company he as supposed to want to lead. > Those employees could have quit and worked somewhere else too. Yes, they could have. And they might have had Eich stayed on. > In a lot of ways that would have been great as they could have cut down on a couple of the pointless projects. Contrary to managements' viewpoint programmers are not fungible, and you can't just drop them into each others projects on a whim. What if the bulk of those that left had worked on FireFox? > By your standard it's impossible for anyone to both have public views that disagree with your own and be the head of any large organization. Why do you think CEOs are normally speaking quite careful about such public statements? Precisely because there is the possibility of backlash. Surely this isn't news. > Money in politics is the great equalizer. It's as democratic as it gets. Abject nonsense. Money in politics means that wealthy people get to vote many more times than poor people. An equalizer should make everybody more equal, not less equal. > Otherwise you end up with a handful of media and tech oligarchs controlling all messaging. Yes, like Rupert Murdoch for instance. Oh, wait.
- koolba 6y ago> Contrary to managements' viewpoint programmers are not fungible, and you can't just drop them into each others projects on a whim. What if the bulk of those that left had worked on FireFox? Salaries are paid in dollars and all dollars are fungible. That money could have been saved for a future date, which is coming sooner than they think, when search referrals will no longer pay the bills. > Abject nonsense. Money in politics means that wealthy people get to vote many more times than poor people. An equalizer should make everybody more equal, not less equal. Oh but it does. The issue you seem to be having is that you do not want anyone to hear opposing view points. If your ideas are so great they should be able to stay standing when the masses learn about alternatives. Or are you scared that it might actually change their minds? >> Otherwise you end up with a handful of media and tech oligarchs controlling all messaging. > Yes, like Rupert Murdoch for instance. Oh, wait. Yes exactly. And also like Mark Zuckerberg, Jack Dorsey, Sundar Pichai... At least with the free flow of money someone working in a non-media industry can channel the fruits of their labors to pay to spread their message. Without that ability you're limited to whatever your media masters decide to let you hear.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI've broadly agreed with you in this thread, mostly, but I have to say that last year one of the interview questions I was asked in a Mozilla interview was "What are you personally doing to encourage diversity?" I felt that that was just a bit hamfisted. All my adult life I've been a feminist [insomuch as a man can be one] and supported this cause. But I had no idea how to answer that question, or I'm pretty sure my answer wasn't satisfactory to the person asking.
- jacquesm 6y agoI would not work for Mozilla for that reason alone. I don't think such a question has a place in a job interview. I also would never ask such a question of an applicant. TMC is a pretty diverse group but we are so by accident, not by design and we take people on merit, not on their level of activism.
- throw7 6y ago> "What are you personally doing to encourage diversity?" What? Are you serious? After browsing through the comments, this here is what really ticks me off and solidifies that mozilla/firefox is in a rotting place right now. sad.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoYeah, serious, I mean I don't disagree with the overall goal of improving diversity in our industry. It's not really improving on its own. But as an established white male who is just an engineer, not a manager or HR staff or director of any kind, etc. almost anything I say in response to that question will just come across as patronizing ("some of my best friends are woman or minority engineers!") I suspect the right answer could be: get out of the way. I did, they hired someone else. I dodged a bullet. I don't think this embrace of social justice stuff has much to do with Mozilla's rot, BTW. Any business without a clear profit/success model and a reasonably sized workforce will just crumble under empire building and competing agendas. The "SJW" stuff is only notorious in our community because of the way the Eich stuff went down. I would have been willing to work for half of what I am now to help make the open internet succeed (well, also to work from home, and to get to work with some friends, and with Rust, and other perks). But that whole interview really soured me. I dodged a bullet anyways.
- roca 6y ago> if Eich wanted to be a contributor to that cause he could have done so silently. He did not deliberately publicise his donation. It was not publicly known until 2012 when someone dug up the records. > Eich very explicitly brought his views into the office in a way that a substantial fraction of Mozilla's employees did not want to be associated with. This is a lie.
- scarface74 6y agoLet’s say that I’m a top notch software engineer working at Mozilla being paid half as much as I could be making at any other Big Tech company because I believe in the mission. Would I believe in the mission if my leadership opposed my fundamental right to be with the person I loved or would I go to one of the other tech companies that are always screaming diversity and pay more? What side of the fence do you think Eich landed on when it came to health benefits for same sex couples?
- pseudalopex 6y agoEich claimed he supported equal rights except for marriage.
- gilrain 6y agoThey're is no "equal" if there is "except for". You'd think a software engineer would grok that instantly.
- coldtea 6y agoActually there is an "equal except for". Isn't that a pretty trivial concept for a software engineer? Here's pseudocode that can be expressed in tons of languages: func compare(a, b) { if typeof(a) == "marriage" and typeof(b) == "marriage": return false; return true; } Ironically, as we're speaking of Brendan, here's a trivial real-life example where this is the actual behavior: in JS all numbers are equal to themselves, except NaN. > typeof 1 'number' > 1 == 1 true > typeof NaN 'number' > NaN == NaN false In any case, it's quite possible for someone religiously motivated to think of marriage as some "holy" union that is only allowed between men and women because the Bible said so or whatever -- but otherwise have no issue with gay civil rights and would be ok with some civic contract with the same exact terms and rights, as long as it's not called "marriage". Marriage being one of the "sacred mysteries" in many versions of christianity and so on.
- scarface74 6y ago
- jboog 6y agoThe CEO of the company spent his personal money so that his gay and lesbian employees could be discriminated against by the government. THAT IS "bringing it in the office"
- stef25 6y agoIt was 12 years ago.
- jboog 6y agoWhat does that have to do with the price of tea in china?
- coldtea 6y agoI find the snark response more "non sequitur" than the grantparent's comment, which at least makes a point. (The point of the phrase "It was 12 years ago" being that: (a) people change with time (b) we should not hold things people did long ago against them forever And thus, that a reaction "but he did X bad thing" to the suggestion of bringing Brendan back is not relevant anymore...
- pseudalopex 6y agoEich stands by his actions. Or he did until recently.
- coldtea 6y agoWhich is totally fine.
- zeveb 6y agoThat is also true of any CEO supporting gun control, and yet the number of CEOs I have seen driven from their jobs for that thoughtcrime is zero.