20 ms·
Well, to be fair, he contributed $1000 to a huge real-life fucking hate mob. Ramble on about 'SJWs' or 'cancel culture' or whatever if you like, but the fact i
by CamperBob2 6y ago
Well, to be fair, he contributed $1000 to a huge real-life fucking hate mob.
Ramble on about 'SJWs' or 'cancel culture' or whatever if you like, but the fact is that social actions have social consequences, and this is an example.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoBut this kind of consequence is just way over the line. We have a legal system where everyone sat down and agreed on very clearly defined appropriate consequences, while cancel culture is just emotionally driven people taking matters into their own hands, not really different from medieval witch hunts.
- Qwertious 6y agoYou do have a legal system, but nobody in this situation did anything illegal. Clearly what "everyone sat down and agreed on" is insufficient, when both sides are saying that "thing X the other party did was legal but inappropriate".
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoThe legal system is absolutely insufficient and there’s no way it can ever not be, but the point is only one party is resorting to mob justice.
- Talanes 6y agoBallot initiatives are just legalized mob justice, so no.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoBallot initiatives aren’t commonly getting random people fired for political wrongthink, so yes.
- CamperBob2 6y agoBut they are (attempting to) use ballot initiatives to deny civil rights to certain people, which if anything is worse than getting people fired. Bottom line: if you contributed to Proposition 8, you did a bad thing, and it needs to hurt. Without a feedback mechanism of some sort, the original 'cancel culture' -- the one that brought us the Dark Ages -- will prevail. As a straight white cis-male, I have no dog in the fight. But I know right from wrong, and Proposition 8 was wrong.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoProposition 8 did not go through because our legal system was doing its job. That’s the feedback mechanism right there. Now if you set up a ballot initiative to fire anyone who contributed to it, then that’s fair game, but obviously any remotely sane judge will deny it. (Which is also the feedback mechanism telling you you’re proposing something extremist here.) Now, circumventing the law to serve your own arbitrary version of justice? Who the hell do you even think you are? Fucking Batman?
- CamperBob2 6y agoBut nobody suggested a ballot initiative to fire anybody. Not everything requires an act of government. Sometimes social pressures are, and should be, sufficient.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoI suggested it, because it would be the correct way to do it, and a good way to realize you’re asking for something extreme. The social pressures you’re advocating are not a weaker form of serving justice. They are stronger. They circumvent our legal system, they’re arbitrary, they’re simply mob justice. No one can keep them in check and indeed they frequently go too far. This is not ok.
- CamperBob2 6y ago