4 ms·
So go range or STAR. The appeal of approval over these is the simplicity while maintaining most properties. I prefer STAR then range then approval. But these ar
by godelski 6y ago
So go range or STAR. The appeal of approval over these is the simplicity while maintaining most properties. I prefer STAR then range then approval. But these are all very close. There's a bigger gap to Condorcet (a class of ranked systems), then big gap to IRV (RCV), then a small gap to FPTP/plurality.
There's a lot more to this than than just these simple options. I suggest you look more into the subject before forming strong opinions. The subject is highly complicated and there is no global optima. There's a lot more to be concerned about besides VSE and solving the spoiler effect (which IRV/RCV doesn't do btw).
Ranked doesn't actually perfectly map. Consider the case where you like two candidates equally? You can't express this with ordinal systems, but you can with cardinal. There are plenty of non-binary selection systems in cardinal votings that allow for more expressiveness. The thing is that this expressiveness doesn't get you much while it adds complexity (granted, not much). But cardinal systems are also fairly resistant to strategic voting (one of those factors that matters).
- eps 6y ago> Consider the case where you like two candidates equally This is an exceptionally improbable case though. Between two choices there's always one that's better. Unlike when you need to select the worst, when all options may be equally bad.
- jabl 6y agoWith an ordinal voting method if you vote A > B > C you're stating that the difference between A and B is the same as the difference between B and C. Which is a poor match to reality.
- eps 6y agoStill way closer to the reality than A = B = C that you get with the approval voting.
- godelski 6y agoYou could just approve A, or A & B. People will set different criteria. The reason equality is a feature is because you can't be infinitely expressive. Let's say that we're using a 5 point scale. If A is 4.9 and B is 4.8 and C is 2, some voters will express both A and B as 5 while some will split. They will do this because they are strategizing (one thing STAR handles well). But the key here, like said before, is that you can express how much more you like A and B over C. This can have major results on the election (also, this ability makes practicality simpler. Less prone to errors because you are scoring candidates and not ranking. So you can have an infinite number of candidates with no added complexity. You can make "mistakes" like scoring or "ranking" the candidates the same value. There are a lot of advantages to the reduced complexity. And you're not making any trades in features, only upgrades).