3 ms·
Let's be real: plurality is trivial, approval is dead simple, score is easy, IRV is so so, Schulze is complex. That is, in determining the winner. In plurality
by godelski 6y ago
Let's be real: plurality is trivial, approval is dead simple, score is easy, IRV is so so, Schulze is complex. That is, in determining the winner.
In plurality you just count the number of votes. Largest number wins. max(sum(votes)
In approval you just count the number of approvals. Candidate with the most approval wins. (max(sum of columns(votes))
Score you actually have to create a matrix!
IRV you have recursion!
Schulze you have both and graph theory!
I just don't see the appeal. Sure, it has a slightly better VSE than STAR if everyone is voting 100% honestly (that condition is a key part!) but it just isn't appealing when you consider other criteria. Especially when we talk about simplicity. Approval is essentially trivial but also has a lot of other criteria going for it. How much does VSE matter? Especially if you still aren't combating spoilers (I'll give you that Schulze does better than IRV at spoilers).