4 ms·
Unfortunately CGP Grey is wrong. RCV (IRV) has been used in Australia for 100+ years. Ireland uses it. We've already had it in America. We've done enough experi
by godelski 6y ago
Unfortunately CGP Grey is wrong. RCV (IRV) has been used in Australia for 100+ years. Ireland uses it. We've already had it in America. We've done enough experimenting. The thing to get excited about is Approval and STAR. Let's interested try cardinal voting systems instead of ordinal. They are also substantially simpler.
- mjevans 6y agoWhat about "Path Vote" AKA the Schulze method? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method "The Schulze method (/ˈʃʊltsə/) is an electoral system developed in 1997 by Markus Schulze that selects a single winner using votes that express preferences. The method can also be used to create a sorted list of winners. The Schulze method is also known as Schwartz Sequential dropping (SSD), cloneproof Schwartz sequential dropping (CSSD), the beatpath method, beatpath winner, path voting, and path winner. The Schulze method is a Condorcet method, which means that if there is a candidate who is preferred by a majority over every other candidate in pairwise comparisons, then this candidate will be the winner when the Schulze method is applied."
- godelski 6y agoCondorcet methods get discussed a lot but they are pretty complicated. I believe that they are discussed because they maximize VSE, such as Schulze. I'll reference my comment in this thread because the VSE link has what I'm talking about. The problem is they are less resistant to strategic voting (though much better than IRV and plurality). But let's just keep it dumb and simple with cardinal systems. Approval is dead simple and gets you pretty much all the way there on most of the criteria. If you want to add a little bit of complexity, STAR makes things even better because it gives you some more specificity (and slightly improves upon score/range). Every time we talk about electronic voting everyone always brings up the matter of simplicity, well, that matters here too. With approval and score you're literally just creating a matrix. STAR you have two rounds (top two from the previous round). Ordinal methods are pretty complex and much more prone to mistakes because of such. You don't need a PhD to understand approval (it is actually how I solve the "where should we eat" problem). [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24563236 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24563236
- ulucs 6y agoSchulze has a very nice geometric interpretation, but I should get off my ass and get the working paper ready to be released first.
- godelski 6y agoLet's be real: plurality is trivial, approval is dead simple, score is easy, IRV is so so, Schulze is complex. That is, in determining the winner. In plurality you just count the number of votes. Largest number wins. max(sum(votes) In approval you just count the number of approvals. Candidate with the most approval wins. (max(sum of columns(votes)) Score you actually have to create a matrix! IRV you have recursion! Schulze you have both and graph theory! I just don't see the appeal. Sure, it has a slightly better VSE than STAR if everyone is voting 100% honestly (that condition is a key part!) but it just isn't appealing when you consider other criteria. Especially when we talk about simplicity. Approval is essentially trivial but also has a lot of other criteria going for it. How much does VSE matter? Especially if you still aren't combating spoilers (I'll give you that Schulze does better than IRV at spoilers).
- jabl 6y agoCome on, just look at the wikipedia page for the Schultze method. There are matrices, graphs, and stuff. That might be fine for a technical community like Debian, but for a society filled with average Joes and Janes, not so much. Democracy needs trust, including the average person being able to understand how something as fundamental as voting works. That's one of the main reasons my favorite is approval voting.
- elihu 6y agoTo expand on your point: there is one specific point that CGP Grey gets wrong in his IRV/RCV videos, which is that he says the system is not worse than first-past-the-post in any way. On the contrary, FPTP adheres to the monotonicity criterion, which means you can't harm your preferred candidate's chances of winning by voting for them. In RCV, you actually can cause your preferred candidate to lose by ranking them too high in some situations. As far as I know, approval voting is strictly equal to or better than FPTP on any reasonable voting system criterion, which I think makes it a better option. Also in its favor is that it's simpler and doesn't tend to eliminate compromise candidates who weren't anyone's first choice. Range and STAR are also both good systems.
- godelski 6y agoWhat criteria is Approval not better than Plurality? Only one I can think of is simplicity (although I'd argue that plurality is only slightly simpler). But approval doesn't have the favorite betrayer like ordinal (RCV/IRV/Condorcet) does. As far as I'm aware, cardinal systems are all like this. They are much more resistant to spoilers.
- elihu 6y agoI think you're in agreement with me, unless I somehow said something backwards. I think that approval is equal to or better than plurality (FPTP) in every criteria I'm aware of. (One criteria you could argue about is later-no-harm; IRV passes, but approval voting does not. It's kind of silly though to say that it's safe in RCV to put lower ranked options below your first choice when in RCV it isn't even always safe to put your first choice first. FPTP adheres to later no harm by not allowing you to vote for anyone but your first choice in the first place, so one could reasonably say that Approval isn't really worse than FPTP, except as a sort of technicality.)
- godelski 6y agoI believe we're in agreement. I was coming to your defense since there seemed to be some confusion among readers who didn't like your extension. Maybe wording? But yeah, I think on basically every metric cardinal is better than ordinal methods which are better than plurality. The whole IRV push seems odd to me when approval (or STAR) is both simpler, responds better to spoilers (the main concern?), and obtains a substantially higher VSE. I don't think IRV solves enough of the problems to make a meaningful difference (I've brought up Australia a lot in this thread).
- joveian 6y agoI don't know about Australia but in Ireland most elections are done with proportional representation and the method is called Single Transferable Vote in that context (and has different properties). According to Wikipedia only the president (a role with little power) and by-elections are single candidate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_the_Republic_of_Ireland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_the_Republic_of_I... IMO, this is a great way to do it and the proportional representation part is more important than the details of voting method.
- godelski 6y agoSTV is IRV (well slight variant: Single Winner STV). Fair Vote has muddled the name by calling it Ranked Choice Voting. This is dumb because there is a class of voting methods where you rank people (ordinal). Ireland is doing better than Australia in terms of party control. > IMO, this is a great way to do it and the proportional representation part is more important than the details of voting method. And I 100% agree with this. The math does too. That's why I advocate so hard for a better voting system. In America we don't have that advantage (I want that too!). But everyone thinks that if we get IRV in Bernie could win. That's not how it works out.