4 ms·
Following in Maine's footsteps, both Massachusetts and Alaska have ballot measures this year to determine whether the states will adopt RCV for various election
by kibwen 6y ago
Following in Maine's footsteps, both Massachusetts and Alaska have ballot measures this year to determine whether the states will adopt RCV for various elections. I believe that anything beyond FPTP is necessary for a healthy democracy in the long run, so I'm crossing my fingers that this can be the beginning of a trend among the states.
The details of the two bills, from https://www.fairvote.org/rcv_2020_ballot_measures https://www.fairvote.org/rcv_2020_ballot_measures:
> Alaskans for Better Elections collected enough signatures to put Ballot Measure 2 to a vote this November. If passed, this ballot measure will implement several changes, including: 1) "top four" blanket primaries for state and congressional offices, where all candidates would appear on the same primary ballot and the top-four vote getters would advance to the general election, regardless of party affiliation; 2) ranked choice voting in the choice among four candidates on the November ballot, with write-in candidates permitted; 3) ranked choice voting in the presidential election among all candidates who have qualified for the ballot and any write-in candidates
> After a multi-year educational campaign led by Voter Choice Massachusetts, an initiative will appear on the ballot as Question 2 that, if passed, would implement ranked choice voting for Massachusetts’ U.S. Senate and U.S House general and primary elections, state primary and general elections, and county offices, beginning in 2022. The initiative is supported by Yes on 2 for Ranked Choice Voting.
(Notably the MA bill doesn't include implementing RCV for the presidential election, but honestly that's not as big a deal as it could be given that the bill does apply to the federal legislative elections; the only reason the presidency has gotten so out of control is because a complicit legislature has allowed it to happen.)
- HaloZero 6y agoI was so surprised that there's more initiatives. It seems Nevada and North Dakota both tried to have things on the ballot but not enough support. Source: https://ballotpedia.org/Ranked-choice_voting_(RCV) https://ballotpedia.org/Ranked-choice_voting_(RCV) Section: Ballot Measures 2020
- godelski 6y agoFargo (ND) actually recently had an election with Approval Voting[0] (which is better at mitigating spoilers, has higher VSE, and is much simpler) [0] https://electionscience.org/commentary-analysis/fargos-first-approval-voting-election-results-and-voter-experience/ https://electionscience.org/commentary-analysis/fargos-first...
- jabl 6y agoThis! For single-winner elections I think approval voting is the best method. (Score voting is in theory slightly better with non-strategic voters, but in practice many people vote strategically in which case the added complexity isn't worth it)
- godelski 6y agoI mean score collapses into approval, so it isn't that big of a deal. I still prefer STAR of the three but I wouldn't be very vocal about voting math if we have approval because it is good enough for me to shut up except among other nerds.
- eps 6y agoLooked it up just now - Approval voting is basically when you can pick more than one candidate off the list, all with equal weights. The candidate with most votes wins. It is a simple scheme, but it's too simple. In reality a voter will prefer one candidate over others and may have a secondary choice so not to see their vote lost. The approval voting means that if your candidate has a decent chance of winning, you will need to vote for this candidate only and no one else. That is, your voting will depend on how well your candidate is doing. An alternative - if I can't have A, then I want B - is the ranked voting. It maps directly on what a voter wants and it doesn't require adjusting their voting strategy based on the standing of their preferred candidate.
- godelski 6y agoSo go range or STAR. The appeal of approval over these is the simplicity while maintaining most properties. I prefer STAR then range then approval. But these are all very close. There's a bigger gap to Condorcet (a class of ranked systems), then big gap to IRV (RCV), then a small gap to FPTP/plurality. There's a lot more to this than than just these simple options. I suggest you look more into the subject before forming strong opinions. The subject is highly complicated and there is no global optima. There's a lot more to be concerned about besides VSE and solving the spoiler effect (which IRV/RCV doesn't do btw). Ranked doesn't actually perfectly map. Consider the case where you like two candidates equally? You can't express this with ordinal systems, but you can with cardinal. There are plenty of non-binary selection systems in cardinal votings that allow for more expressiveness. The thing is that this expressiveness doesn't get you much while it adds complexity (granted, not much). But cardinal systems are also fairly resistant to strategic voting (one of those factors that matters).