4 ms·
Not that it matters this time, there being no third party candidates of note in Maine. If Florida had ranked voting in 2000, Al Gore would be President. Florid
by Animats 6y ago
Not that it matters this time, there being no third party candidates of note in Maine. If Florida had ranked voting in 2000, Al Gore would be President.
Florida 2000:
Bush 2,912,790
Gore 2,912,253
Nader 97,488
Buchanan 17,484
Browne 16,415
Others < 6,000
- lakala6790 6y agoAnd Hillary Clinton as well if I recall correctly.
- nl 6y agoI don't think that is obviously true. Stein and the Green Party finished behind the Libertarian Party by a signification margin. What states would have switched? In Wisconsin Clinton + Stein did outpoll Trump alone (by ~10K votes), but the Libertarian party had another 106K votes that would have been allocated and it's not hard to imagine Trump getting more than Clinton of them. It was a similar story in Pennsylvania and Michigan.
- sigstoat 6y agos/If Florida had ranked voting in 2000/& and the candidates, campaigns, and voters all behaved as though it didn't/
- tyrust 6y agoYou're technically correct, but how do you think people would behave differently with ranked-choice voting?
- throwaheyy 6y agoThey can vote for candidates other than the top 2 without wasting their vote. Because when any candidate is eliminated, their votes flow to each voter’s next preference. That encourages co-operation between coalitions of candidates instead of polarization of only 2.
- hazz99 6y agoI’m Australian and I consciously vote very differently. My first votes are for small parties that are very unlikely to get elected but who’s campaign largely rests on an issue I support. This encourages the other, more popular parties to adopt that issue if they see these parties are popular. Otherwise I’d just vote for the “best” and most popular.
- godelski 6y agoI'd like to point out that Australia is still dominated by two parties even with the benefit of the parliamentary system (giving proportionate seats to other parties). This forces two major coalitions which isn't extremely different.
- hazz99 6y agoYeah, it’s not ideal. I’m no political scientist though, I’m just sharing my own motivations and voting patterns under a different system.
- godelski 6y agoI just want to point it out because I strongly advocate for cardinal systems like Approval or STAR (I also like proportionate representation). The big reason is that we have a 100+ year experiment that disprove Fair Vote's (the one pushing RCV/IRV) largest claim: "solving the spoiler effect." The math doesn't side with the claim either, but Australia is a fantastic experiment. So if we're going to do something new, why not better? Especially if better is also simpler (approval is near trivial).
- nl 6y agoThis is true in the lower house, but not in the upper house (the senate) where there are 5 significant parties holding seats (counting the LNP coalition as one party and the Centre Alliance as a significant party) plus some independents, and no natural majority across any combination[1]. [1] https://www.aph.gov.au/Senators_and_Members/Senators/Senate_composition https://www.aph.gov.au/Senators_and_Members/Senators/Senate_...
- sigstoat 6y agoi don't know or (in this case) care what would be different. (and i say that as a fan of RCV and similar). i'm just tired of people positing counterfactual worlds, and assuming whatever tiny little change they make will have no ramifications except for the one that they want. it is sloppy thinking.
- tyrust 6y agoGotcha. The parent comment should have said that it "might have" changed the outcome.
- 6chars 6y ago20 years is quite the tenure for a president
- burlesona 6y agoAnd if there’d been ranked choice voting in 92, Bush Sr. would likely have won over Bill Clinton.
- godelski 6y agoYou can't get a winner for ranking (or even ordinal) when you made people vote singular. These numbers give us no insight into how much or how little voters liked/approved of the other candidates. It is likely that Nader voters would have also approved Gore, but it also wouldn't be surprising if Gore voters approved Nader and he came out on top. It gets much trickier than just assigning votes over.
- elihu 6y agoIt's also possible that some Nader voters wouldn't have entered a second choice, or that the balance of 1st and 2nd choices between Nader and Gore would have resulted in a non-monotonic outcome (i.e. some group of voters cause, for instance, Gore to lose to Bush because too many of them entered Gore as their first choice; that can actually happen with RCV, which is why I am uncomfortable having the integrity of our democracy depend on that particular voting system).
- godelski 6y agoYes, despite Fair Vote's claim IRV doesn't solve the issue of spoilers. Despite the 100+ years of experimentation and despite the math. I'm always confused why there isn't a bigger push for methods like Approval and STAR. They are dead simple and solve the issues. The conspiracy theorist in me (joking) says its because it would actually change things where IRV won't.
- elihu 6y agoI think part of it is that people tend to be laser-focused on the problem they're having right now and not the problem they're going to have. For instance, RCV (aka IRV) is great solution to the problem that a minor candidate siphoned a few votes away from a major candidate and swung the results of a national presidential election several times in recent memory. If voters who really wanted to vote for Nader could have also voted for Gore, maybe Bush wouldn't have won, and that election would have better reflected the will of voters. The problem that RCV is not prepared to deal with is what happens if people actually start voting for Green or Libertarian or Democratic Socialist or whatever in large enough numbers that they actually have a chance of winning elections. At that point, you run into problems and RCV starts producing nonsensical results. The voters learn from this that it's not actually safe to vote for third party candidates, and the two party system remains in place. It's a little bit better because you don't have minor candidates swinging elections, but it's still a duopoly.
- tptacek 6y agoIt has already mattered downticket; it is, I think? part of the reason Jared Golden now represents ME-02.