3 ms·
The word that comes to mind for Steve Gibson is "kook". Not in a nasty way, just the sort of person who keeps sending purported proofs of the abc conjecture to
by tialaramex 6y ago
The word that comes to mind for Steve Gibson is "kook". Not in a nasty way, just the sort of person who keeps sending purported proofs of the abc conjecture to a University mathematics professor they met briefly twenty years ago, or who frequently writes to their senator with opinions about a show they saw on TV. Harmless yet somehow mildly annoying.
But as to that fingerprints page. The idea isn't really about any problem with the Web PKI (what you're calling "the CA hierarchy"). Instead it's about a method you can try to use to figure out if you're using a client that's configured to trust something else entirely. In most cases this means a middlebox, maybe at a school (to stop kids looking at porn and maybe cheating on tests) or at work (porn again, and maybe other non-work stuff, sometimes anti-exfiltration technology) but it could be your own AV software.
It can't really do what it says on the tin, for a few reasons. You're going to get some false alerts this way because the certificate Steve (and Steve's web site) sees won't necessarily match the one you see, and if a sophisticated adversary was trying to defeat Steve's system they could just use the same technique to replace Steve's own site.
Also as often happens with these little projects, it isn't properly maintained. The stuff about EV in Firefox (and I think Chrome too?) is no longer true.
- hamburglar 6y agoAh, you're right, I didn't actually read through the alarmist stuff to see that he was referring to MITM proxies that actually install their own roots on your machines. Now I'm amused at the idea that there could be some off the shelf MITM proxy out there that simply does content editing to replace any occurrences of the FP of the real cert they're MITM'ing with the FP of the cert they generated for you on the fly. :D When I saw the alarmist stuff about knowing the cert fingerprints for certain sites a priori, I thought he'd invented a crazy ad hoc version of cert pinning and just rolled my eyes.