15 ms·
I suspect the schools are trying to curate their student body so it doesn't turn into a freak show, which would itself reduce prestige. It would be like a zoo t
by analog31 6y ago
I suspect the schools are trying to curate their student body so it doesn't turn into a freak show, which would itself reduce prestige. It would be like a zoo that contains exactly one species of animal. This is the dilemma. Taking the top 1000 scorers on some particularly difficult exam, and putting them all together in one place, would be a freak show. Not because they are freaks per se, but because any monoculture of an extreme trait will turn itself into a freak show.
- saagarjha 6y agoPerfect students are not “freaks”.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoOn the other hand, a Mensa gathering (not a member, myself) is one of the few situations I've been in that was hard to characterize as anything other than freakshow on earth. Shows that you can maximize a single dimension so much that you are left with people incapable of communication. Similarly, an organization of students maximizing academic performance has a certain vibe that definitely doesn't feel "perfect". It doesn't even seem like that useful of a skill, but I'd have to know the purpose of a uni to comment further.
- Alekhine 6y agoMensa is for those who are insecure about their intelligence and like the idea that they can easily rank themselves above others with a number designed to check if you're mentally handicapped. I'm not surprised they can't communicate.
- analog31 6y agoI always thought to myself, what if I take the test and pass it? Then what? If I fail, that's easy. I lick my wounds and go home. But if I pass? The shape of the distribution -- basically slicing off one end of a bell curve -- means that in all likelihood, I would be at the lower end of the IQ scale within the group, even if at the upper end within the overall population. So I'd be taking a test and paying money for the privilege of being the dumbest person in the room. It hardly seemed attractive to me.
- User23 6y agoAlso pure test based admission ends up being something around 75% asian, 15% white, and 10% others. See Stuyvesant for example[1]. For some reason Harvard feels like being 75-80% Asian would be bad for their brand so they got sued for discrimination. But Harvard is Harvard and it's hard to win a lawsuit against an institution that is that well connected. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuyvesant_High_School#Demographics_and_alleged_discrimination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuyvesant_High_School#Demogra...
- woodruffw 6y agoAs someone who went to one of those “pure test based” NYC schools: this is not the testament that you think it is. The number of Black and Hispanic students at Stuyvesant and Bronx Science was an order of magnitude higher in the 1970s; the current demographics are a consequence of paid preparation being a reliable way to score highly on the SHSAT.
- sprafa 6y agoIt’s amazing that people don’t realise this. I always think back to the study that showed the amount of books in a household was a strong predictor for IQ. Background matters a whole lot, but high performance people don’t want to hear it, because they want to feel like it’s all their own credit. Nope. Just like money, there’s also an intellectual family bank that gets inherited. And it’s not genes, it’s access to knowledge which is purchased by capital.
- secondcoming 6y agoWas that study done before everyone had an internet connection?
- kube-system 6y agoAll studies ever have been done before everyone had an internet connection.