6 ms·
Atlas Winced
- nhangen 16y agoI hope the OP isn't posting this simply because it's fun to bash Rand. I'm a huge fan of the book (though I prefer the Fountainhead), but didn't expect much more from this movie. I haven't seen it yet, but with that cast, and a production team that can't even hire a logo designer (check the stock vector used for the signage logo), I'd expect nothing short of a disappointment.
- sudonim 16y agoI didn't get the sense that the article was critical of Rand. It seemed more like it was bashing the movie. An Atlas Shrugged movie could be awesome. The book conjures such vivid images of grandeur and destruction. It's a shame this trilogy seems like it should be missed.
- nhangen 16y agoI agree with you, but I've seen so many reviews use this bad movie as a chance to bash Rand that I was hoping to avoid that here. This one has had a lot of troubles getting off the ground, and I'm guessing that the film reflects that, which as you say, is sad.
- davidmathers 16y agoI hope the OP isn't posting this simply because it's fun to bash Rand. The OP is Jane Galt: http://www.janegalt.net/ http://www.janegalt.net/
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- simonsarris 16y agoIf you are looking for other reviews, Metacritic (27%): http://www.metacritic.com/movie/atlas-shrugged-part-i http://www.metacritic.com/movie/atlas-shrugged-part-i Rotten Tomatoes (10%): http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/atlas_shrugged_part_i/ http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/atlas_shrugged_part_i/
- omouse 16y agoDoes anyone here actually like Ayn Rand and her writings?
- marknutter 16y agoAlthough you're being condescending, I'll answer you honestly: yes.
- nhangen 16y agoThe Fountainhead is my favorite piece of fiction, and though Atlas Shrugged isn't it my top 5, I'm a huge fan of her philosophy. So yes.
- maxharris 16y agoI love Ayn Rand! Atlas Shrugged had a huge, positive impact on my life, and it's still my favorite novel over a decade after I first read it. I love the way that Rand stylizes her characters because it makes for very clear mental images while reading. It also it creates the framework for all kinds of subtle things that you don't notice the first time through.
- rbanffy 16y agoA little bit too preachy, but we need the extremist thinkers to keep the Overton window from sliding.
- relic17 16y agoAnother honest answer - yes. I read her work only recently and was surprised to find out that she confirmed many of the conclusions I had reached, often quite painfully, myself. She provided the philosophical (theoretical) framework for those conclusions, which further helped me connect the outstanding dots. She urges people to relentlessly ask the question why, to examine every premise for every important idea that guides our lives, to follow that premise to its roots, to look for contradictions. I put in the effort to do just that with her philosophy, and that effort matched the brainpower I had needed to build some of my most complex programs and models. I am 30 now, but I really wish to have read her work when I was 20. If I could offer any advice, it is to read her books before you reach 30 and to think deeply about what she has to say until you are convinced (based on your best effort and knowledge to date) that you either agree or disagree with her. This would be much better than taking someone else's word for it.
- wmeredith 16y agoThis is really too bad. I loved the book (in spite of it's heavy-handed preaching) and was always afraid this would happen in transition to the big screen.
- blhack 16y agoOh come on, the movie wasn't that terrible. I saw it yesterday morning in a completely sold out theater (every showing has been sold out so far, with a line around the theater of people trying to get in). My "exit polls" (overhearing people talk about it as we all shuffle out) indicate that most people enjoyed it. Sure it wasn't transformers, it was slow (but somehow not slow enough), and not very nuanced (the dialog the article is talking about), but it was an alright way to spend 105 minutes. If you're a fan of film, I think you should go see it, if for no reason other than to try and see how the producers are trying to translate the story to film. It's also pretty culturally significant. Hopefully with enough interest (and money) the second one will be done properly.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Tycho 16y agowell the discussion about the film on objectivismonline.net has been mostly negative in the lead up to release. i think fans of the book are more likely to slaughter it for blowing a glorious opportunity to bring the philosophy to the mainstream.
- icey 16y agoErg, sorry for being a deletionist. On reread I noticed my statement wasn't very well thought out. Didnt think that anyone had seen it yet :(
- gnosis 16y agoAyn Rand was an admirer of child killer William Hickman, who dismembered a little girl. http://michaelprescott.net/hickman.htm http://michaelprescott.net/hickman.htm
- rbanffy 16y agoAd hominem fallacy this early in the morning? I don't have to remind you one lapse of judgment doesn't invalidate all of one's ideas. (and, to be fair, I think Ayn Rand's "wisdom" is highly overrated)
- gnosis 16y agoIt's not an ad hominem, since I wasn't trying to refute Rand's arguments (such as they are). It's quite telling, however, that that was the sort of man she idolized.
- Tycho 16y agoThe author of that article did not really give an honest interpretation of what was written in her diaries (about Hickman).
- gnosis 16y agoCare to elaborate?
- Tycho 16y agoThe author ignores that Rand would have quite limited access to information on the whole story, for a start. But more importantly he deliberately downplays the fiction/adaptation angle. Rand was fascinated by what she glimpsed in the news story (namely the 'I am like the state; what's good for me is right' quote, and the mob-mentality of the public reaction), because it gave her some ideas for a work of fiction, regardless of the facts of this particular case. Writers don't have to be accountable for what strange things inspire them, just what they actually publish. Prescott leaves the exhonerating quote to the very end (padding the rest of the article out with random references to Neitsche and snippets of unrelated dialogue grabbed without context): ------------ "I am afraid that I idealize Hickman and that he might not be this at all. In fact, he probably isn't. But it does not make any difference. If he isn't, he could be, and that's enough. There is a lot that is purposely, senselessly horrible about him. But that does not interest me..." ------------ She freely admits that her impressions of the case are probably wrong, but it rightfully doesn't matter to her because she's just planning how to create a work of fiction based on some ideas it brought to mind, not publish an editorial on the Hickman trial. When you untangle the whole business, that's all you're left with: a novelist who privately took inspiration from a strange/shocking event, but did nothing to sanction or glorify it in the resulting fiction. Not particularly unusual: look at all the characters, tyrants etc., that Shakespeare put in his plays while finding profound truths about humanity. I'd say the whole thing would be analogous to me turning on the news, listening to something Col. Gidaffi was saying in defiance of the hypocritical NATO alliance, and then (without having the luxury or desire to research Gidaffi's own integrity), being inspired to write a story about a benign dictator who brought prosperity to the land, loosely basing him on Gidaffi's mannerisms. So really there's nothing to it, and that article would have died a quiet death, EXCEPT for this passage: "The first thing that impresses me about the case is the ferocious rage of a whole society against one man. No matter what the man did, there is always something loathsome in the 'virtuous' indignation and mass-hatred of the 'majority.'... It is repulsive to see all these beings with worse sins and crimes in their own lives, virtuously condemning a criminal..." Now that is a horrible thing for Rand to say - most people have worse sins than child murder?? But this is where Michael Prescott has 'done the dirty' - the sentence I italicized was, if you read the whole passage from the diary, not referring specifically to this murder case, but to the general instances of mob indignation (eg. could be tax evasion cases, MP expense fiddling, bankers bonuses, Monica Lewinsky, Fred Goodwin, the BP ceo, public figures making un-PC remarks, etc). Which is not an altogether unfair observation, in my experience. Mass self-righteousness is seldom pretty.
- daimyoyo 16y agoThere are several things to consider before seeing this movie. First and foremost, it's an ashcan project. The film had to be rushed into production to retain the film rights, so the writers didn't have the time to prune out lines like the one mentioned. Also, Atlas Shrugged and The Lord of the Rings are nearly the same length, yet this film is just over half the run time of The Fellowship. Finally, the budget of this film is not nearly what it needed to be, so don't go in expecting to see a visual masterpiece. It's a shame but maybe someday a Peter Jackson level director will give this story the proper treatment it deserves.